Small Wars Journal

A Tribute to Captain Travis Patriquin

Wed, 12/08/2010 - 1:37pm
A Tribute to Captain Travis Patriquin:

America's "Lawrence of Arabia" in Ramadi

by Chad M. Pillai

December 6, 2010 marked the 4th anniversary of the loss of America's "Lawrence of Arabia" in Ramadi. On that day, U.S. Army Captain Travis Patriquin along with Marine Corps Major Megan McClung and Army Specialist Vincent Pomante III were killed in Ar Ramadi by an Improvised Explosive Device (IED). The tragedy marked the end of Travis's remarkable career and tireless efforts to win the "Battle of Ramadi" in 2006. Travis was a unique and unconventional thinker whom I had the pleasure of working with, we worked together as Brigade Operations Planners and in Iraq as Civil-Military Operations Officers. He arrived at the 1st Brigade, 1st Armored Division (Ready First Combat Team) with an extremely valuable skill set needed for a successful counterinsurgency campaign -- fluent in the local languages and cultures. Travis's experience as an enlisted intelligence analysis with the Special Forces serving in South America and subsequent language and cultural immersion training in Jordan created an officer fluent in Spanish, Arabic, and Pashtu. Immediately after 9-11 and the start of Operation Enduring Freedom, Travis deployed to Afghanistan and served during Operation Anaconda and the U.S. push to remove the Taliban from power.

In early 2005, Travis arrived in Germany to serve with the 1st Brigade. Upon notification of our deployment to Iraq, Travis volunteered his time to train officers selected for civil-military operations in language and cultural immersion classes. In the months leading up to our deployment, many of us were trained to read some basic Arabic, but more importantly, develop a greater appreciation for Muslim and Arabic culture to plan and prepare for future operations.

From January to June 2006, I served with Travis in Tal Afar, Iraq, after the transfer of responsibility from the 3rd ACR. During that period of time Travis and I worked to rebuild the shattered city and gain the support of the local populace. Working with Travis I was able to develop a clearer picture of the tribal dynamics of Tal Afar with its mixed population of Sunni and Shia Turkmen and develop a road map for political and economic development which eventually led to reintegration of neighborhoods (Major Neil Smith's campaign in Sa'ad, for example), the expansion of the Iraq Police, development of a small business center, illiteracy programs, and the successful (symbolic) development and passing of the Tal Afar district operating budget by the governing council and Mayor Najim. Travis's greatest impact came when the Brigade was ordered to Ar Ramadi.

When Patriquin arrived in Ramadi he studied what happened to the Abu Mahal in western Anbar Province. He instinctively knew that if a tribe challenged Al Qaeda it should be the primary goal of the U.S. to defend and strengthen that new ally. Al Qaeda's ruthless intimidation campaign in Ramadi led to one of the deepest personal friendship and tactical alliance between the Ready First Combat Team commanded by COL Sean McFarland and Sheikh Sittar Abu Risha. Travis clearly understood that Al Qaeda's murder of a local sheikh and the dishonor displayed to the family by not returning the body to the family was the pivotal point in which the local Sunni insurgency could be redirected away from attacking U.S. forces and toward Al Qaeda's corrupt and alien interpretation of Islam. From this relationship, the Anbar Awakening took a life of its own which would eventually spread throughout Iraq. The basic principles was simplistically demonstrated in Travis's famous "How to Win in Al Anbar" stick-man PowerPoint presentation.

Task Force 2-37 (the remaining element of the Ready First) redeployed from Tal Afar in October 2006 to Ar Ramadi. My immediate priority was to discuss with Travis his thoughts and ideas about Ramadi and how to incorporate the successful lessons learned in Tal Afar. Within a matter of weeks Travis introduced me to all the critical sheikhs in my Task Force area of operations to include Sheikh Sittar and his family. These introductions and key insights into the power players in the region allowed the Brigade and Task Force to accelerate the Anbar Awakening to include the local Iraqi Police, create Local Security Battalions (forerunner of the "Sons of Iraq"), and create a localized political and economic confederation of tribes through the creation of the Jazeera Council. It was the Jazeera Council that provided the incentives for tribes to join the local alliance to defeat Al Qaeda. From November 2006 through February 2007 all the tribal areas in the sector north of the city had switched from pro-Al Qaeda to pro-Jazeera council members. It was through learning from Travis about the tribes and my introduction to Sheikh Sittar and his brother that made that possible.

Sadly, on the 6th of December 2006, a day that important development work was being done with the chief of the Jazeera Council, I heard the news of Travis's death. The image remains with me to this day as of the smoke plume from the IED that had just detonated. At that moment I not only lost three friends (Travis, MAJ McClung, and SPC Pomante) but also my mentor and comedic partner in our struggle to reclaim Ramadi from Al Qaeda.

The death of Travis and six others (3 more Marines and Soldiers died that day in Ramadi) was not only an unfortunate loss for our unit but also a loss for our nation. His loss not only impacted our unit, it also touched Sheikh Sittar who named a new Iraqi Police Station after Travis in Ramadi. One can only speculate what his career would have been after Ramadi and how he could possibly helped in our fight against Al Qaeda and the Taliban in Afghanistan. I once joked with Travis that he need to get the encyclopedia inside his head committed to paper. Sadly, he never did, though he did publish an article for Military Review. Thankfully, author William Doyle will soon publish "A Soldier's Dream: Captain Travis Patriquin and the Awakening of Iraq" in the summer of 2011.

On December 6, 2010, America lost its young "Lawrence of Arabia" in Ramadi, hopefully he will never be forgotten and will be studied as an important part of counterinsurgency history, theory, and practice.

Major Chad M. Pillai, FA 59 currently serves as a strategic planner for HQDA G-3/5/7 War Plans Division. He served as the Civil-Military Operations Officer for Task Force 2-37, 1st Brigade/1st Armored Division (Ready First Combat Team) from 2005-2007 alongside Captain Travis Patriquin. Major Pillai earned a Masters Degree in International Public Policy from the Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies (SAIS). Major Pillai published "Adult Education in Afghanistan" July-August 2009 Military Review and "Tal Afar and Ar Ramadi: Grass Roots Reconstruction"

March-April 2009 Military Review.

8 December SWJ Roundup

Wed, 12/08/2010 - 8:06am
Afghanistan

Afghan War Review Called Likely to Show Progress - New York Times

Petraeus' Negative Tone at Odds with Obama's Optimism - Stars and Stripes

Gates Visits Afghanistan Bases - American Forces Press Service

In Visit, Gates Reminded of Tough Fight Troops Face - Washington Post

Gates Gets Sobering War Update on Afghan Visit - Los Angeles Times

U.S. General Declares Fight for Southern Afghan Town 'Over' - Bloomberg

U.S. General: Battle in Marjah is Over - Associated Press

Petraeus: Forces in Afghanistan Continue to Push Enemy - AFPS

Coalition Turns Corner in Afghanistan's Helmand Province - AFPS

Why IEDs are Taking a Mounting Toll - Christian Science Monitor

Catch-and-Release of Taliban Fighters Angers Troops - Washington Examiner

Video Thought to Show American Held in Afghanistan - Associated Press

Arrest Made in Afghan Woman's Disfigurement Case - New York Times

Foreign Air Strike Kills 2 Afghan Troops - Reuters

What's at Stake in AfPak - Washington Times opinion

Pakistan

Official in Pakistan Escapes Assassination Bid - New York Times

Suicide Bomb Kills 15 at Market in Northwest Pakistan - BBC News

Suicide Bomber Kills 14 In Northwest Pakistan - Reuters

Iraq

Iraq's Allawi Threatening to Quit Government - Voice of America

Troops Re-doubling Advise, Assist Efforts in Iraq - American Forces Press Service

Roadside Bombing Wounds 7 Iranian Pilgrims in Iraq - Associated Press

Iran

Iran Talks End with Little Sign of Progress - Washington Post

No Progress Evident in Iran Nuclear Talks - Los Angeles Times

More Nuclear Talks With Iran Are Set - New York Times

Iran Agrees to 2011 Talks in Turkey - Associated Press

Iran Will Not Bargain Over Nuclear Rights in Future Talks - Voice of America

Korean Peninsula

U.S. Sends Top Officials to China over N. Korea - Associated Press

Mullen Arrives in South Korea to Address Tensions - AFPS

U.S. Military Chief Criticizes China Over North Korea - New York Times

Mullen Scolds China for its 'Tactic Approval' - Washington Post

Mullen Blasts China for Not Using Influence - Stars and Stripes

U.S. Commander Urges China to Act on North Korea - BBC News

U.S. Urges Strong Trilateral Alliance With Seoul, Tokyo - Reuters

S. Korea, U.S. Hold Military Talks on N. Korea - Associated Press

North Korea Conducts "Drill," U.S. Military Chief in Seoul - Reuters

N.M. Gov. Bill Richardson May Head to North Korea - Washington Post

WikiLeaks

WikiLeaks, Round Three - Small Wars Journal (post-release - cutoff 8 Dec)

SWJ Wikileaks Roundup - Small Wars Journal (pre-release)

London Court Denies WikiLeaks Founder Bail - Voice of America

British Court Denies Bail to Assange - New York Times

WikiLeaks Founder Julian Assange Arrested - Los Angeles Times

Assange's Arrest in Britain Complicates Efforts to Extradite - Washington Post

U.S. May Seek Extradition of WikiLeaks Founder Assange - Los Angeles Times

Australia Blames U.S. for Wikileaks - BBC News

Australia Blames U.S. Over WikiLeaks, Founder Held In U.K. - Reuters

Justice Department Studies WikiLeaks Prosecution - New York Times

Saudis Proposed Lebanon Offensive - The Guardian

Wikileaks: Saudis Urge Force to Destroy Hezbollah - BBC News

Clinton: Pakistani Militants Ran Group from Jail - Washington Times

WikiLeaks: Libya Threatened U.K. Over Jailed Bomber - Reuters

Wikileaks: U.K. 'Feared Megrahi Prison Death' - BBC News

Ortega has Received 'Suitcases of Cash' from Venezuela - Los Angeles Times

NATO Developed Secret Contingency Plans for Baltic States - Der Spiegel

Russia Objects to NATO Plan to Defend Baltics - Associated Press

On the Trail of Weapons Smugglers - Der Spiegel

A Difficult U.S. Fight to Choke Off Terror Finance - Der Spiegel

WikiLeaks Hasn't Fulfilled Financial-aid Pledge to Manning - Washington Post

Julian Assange: Neocon Tool? - New York Times opinion

WikiLeaks Upside - Washington Times opinion

Sunny Days for Gitmo - Washington Times opinion

Take our Prisoner, Please - Washington Times opinion

U.S. Department of Defense

Panel: Let Women Serve in Combat Roles - Marine Corps Times

Army Struggles with Mental Health Amid 2 Long Wars - Associated Press

Navy Railgun Moves Closer to Real Use - Fredericksburg Free Lance-Star

United States

Federal Judge Tosses CIA Targeted Killing Lawsuit - Washington Post

Targeted Killing Lawsuit Thrown Out - New York Times

Punting on Awlaki? - Los Angeles Times editorial

Some Ex-Detainees Still Tied to Terror - New York Times

Report: 2 Ex-detainees Returned to Terrorism - Washington Post

Report: Gitmo Transfers Return to Terrorism - Washington Times

House Republican Leaders Select Committee Chairmens - New York Times

Africa

U.S. Urges Ivory Coast's Gbagbo to Accept Election Defeat - Voice of America

Ivory Coast: U.N. Calls on Gbagbo to Step Down - Associated Press

W. African Leaders Suspend Ivory Coast Over Political Crisis - Voice of America

Ivory Coast Minister Predicts Power-Sharing - Associated Press

Ivory Coast Crisis: Liberia Warlords Told Not to Meddle - BBC News

E.U. Force: Somali Pirates Cannot be Stopped by Force - BBC News

Nigeria: Former Dictator May Leave Ruling Party - Associated Press

Guinea's New President Hopes to Ease Tensions - Voice of America

Americas and Caribbean

U.S. Officials Met With Alleged Boy Hitman in Mexico - Associated Press

Candidates Face Runoff in Haiti's Troubled Vote - New York Times

Furious Protests Greet Haiti Election Results - Associated Press

Haiti Cholera Likely From U.N. Troops, Expert Says - Associated Press

Asia Pacific

19 Countries to Skip Nobel, China Offers Its Own Prize - New York Times

China Cites International Support for Anti-Nobel Stand - Voice of America

China to Award Prize to Rival Nobel - Associated Press

China to Award Own Peace Prize Ahead Of Nobel Award - Reuters

U.S. Lawmakers Honor Chinese Nobel Peace Prize Winner Liu Xiaobo - VOA

China Ignores Vatican Protest, Chooses Church Leaders - Washington Post

U.S. and China Narrow Differences at Climate Talks - New York Times

China: Hesitant Titan - Washington Post opinion

Russia Says No Violation Near U.S.-Japan Drills - Reuters

Philippine Court Rules Anti-Corruption Panel Illegal - New York Times

Europe

Moscow, E.U. Reach Deal for Russian WTO Membership - Voice of America

Georgia Arrests Six People in Bombings - New York Times

Georgia Arrests 6, Calling Them Agents for Russia - Associated Press

Increased German Police Patrols Linked to Terrorism Threat - Stars and Stripes

Debt-hit Irish Publish Harshest Budget in History - Associated Press

Middle East

U.S. Drops Bid to Sway Israel on Settlements - New York Times

U.S. Abandons Push for Renewal of Israeli Settlement Freeze - Washington Post

U.S. Dropping Demand Israel Freeze Settlement Building - Los Angeles Times

Obama Ends Push for Israeli-settlements Halt - Washington Times

Middle East Peace Talks 'Crisis' Over Settlement Row - BBC News

Palestinians Question U.S. Ability to Forge Peace - Associated Press

Peace Process In Crisis; Palestinians Doubt U.S. - Reuters

Palestinians, Some Israelis Work to Ease Tensions in West Bank - VOA

Israeli-Palestinian Security Coordinated - Washington Times

Analysis: U.S. Wary of Pushing Egypt on Flawed Vote - Associated Press

South Asia

India on Alert as Bomb Hits Hindu Holy City - New York Times

India on High Alert after Varanasi City Blast - BBC News

Police Question Brothers in India Holy City Blast - Associated Press

Indian Federal Agents Go After Ex-Minister - Reuters

Informed Dissent

Tue, 12/07/2010 - 8:08pm
Informed Dissent: One Blogger's Critique of the Afghan War - New York Times book review by C.J. Chivers. Review of Joshua Foust's Afghanistan Journal: Selections From Registan.net. BLUF: "Mr. Foust, though he has softened his language and tone lately, often does not play nice. Few are spared in these pages - generals, diplomats, think-tankers, authors and journalists all suffer Mr. Foust's sting. This wide target selection fits a binding theme. In his assessment, the problems facing the United States in Afghanistan effort are not just grand in scale and complexity, but also, more worriedly, largely misunderstood by those guiding Afghanistan and the West through the war."

Registan.net, a blog focusing on Central Asian affairs, can be found here.

New CNAS Report on Responsible Transition in Afghanistan (Updated)

Tue, 12/07/2010 - 4:52pm
Via e-mail: The Center for a New American Security (CNAS) released today a new report on U.S. Afghanistan strategy authored by CNAS Senior Advisor and Senior Fellow Lieutenant General David W. Barno, USA (Ret.), former commander of U.S. and Coalition Forces in Afghanistan; and Fellow Andrew Exum, a former Army Ranger and civilian advisor to General Stanley McChrystal. In Responsible Transition: Securing U.S. Interests in Afghanistan Beyond 2011, the authors lay out a strategy for the post-July 2011 phase of the war, define the U.S. troop presence and commitment beyond 2014, and offer operational and strategic guidance for protecting U.S. and allied long-term interests in Afghanistan and Pakistan.

In Responsible Transition, Barno and Exum provide policy recommendations - military and political - for how the United States and its NATO allies can get from summer 2011, when U.S. and coalition troops begin to draw down in Afghanistan, to 2014, when U.S. forces transition to a residual force and transfer full leadership of operations to Afghan security forces. Barno and Exum also consider "spoilers," or disruptive events, that could affect the success of any plan, including: a terror attack on U.S. soil originating in Pakistan; an adversarial Pakistan; a resurgent Taliban; and Afghan National Security Forces failure.

Update: "A Responsible Transition", a response by Joshua Foust at Registan.net.

Better civil defense preparation will show that South Korea is serious

Tue, 12/07/2010 - 12:16pm
Kim Kwan-jin, South Korea's new defense minister (and a former four-star general), now says that South Korea will respond to future North Korean military attacks with airstrikes on North Korean targets.

There is a simple and well-known reason why successive South Korean governments have not explicitly made such a public commitment in the past: much of Seoul lies within range of thousands of North Korean cannons and battlefield missiles. That vulnerability has provided the North with "escalation dominance," a fact which hasn't changed even if resolve in South Korea may now be stiffening.

As long as Seoul's vulnerability persists, many will doubt the sincerity of General Kim's retaliatory threat. The most important of these doubters would be decision-makers inside North Korea, who seems to relish an exciting game of chicken.

The South Korean government could remove doubts about the credibility of its policy if it got serious about civil defense preparation in Seoul and elsewhere. According to South Korea's Yonhap News, current civil defense preparation consists of a short perfunctory drill eight times per year, plus four hours of video-watching by a civil defense cadre. That's no preparation for a huge and complicated city like Seoul.

Serious civil defense preparation would be highly disruptive, economically costly, and a bit frightening for many. But it would also be a test of how seriously South Korea's population views its problem with the North. A serious public response might do more than anything tried thus far to persuade the North's leaders that future provocations won't pay. And until the South can show some seriousness about civil defense, its promise to retaliate after the next attack will lack credibility.

7 December SWJ Roundup

Tue, 12/07/2010 - 7:12am
Afghanistan

Pakistani Militias Offer Lessons for U.S. in Afghanistan - Washington Post

Secretary of Defense Gates Arrives in Afghanistan - New York Times

Gates in Afghanistan to View Progress, Meet Troops - Associated Press

British PM in Unannounced Visit to Afghanistan - Associated Press

British Prime Minister Makes Trip to Afghanistan - Reuters

U.K.: Cameron Looks to 2011 to Start Afghan Withdrawal - Associated Press

U.K.: Cameron Eyes 2011 Afghan Pullback - Reuters

Wikileaks Cables 'Will Not Damage U.K.-Afghan Relations' - BBC News

U.S.: 'Encouraging' Signs in Afghanistan, But 2014 Pullout Uncertain - VOA

Time, Trust Key to Progress in Afghanistan - American Forces Press Service

Afghanistan Softens Ban on Private Security Firms - New York Times

Karzai Abandons Plan to Scrap Private Security Firms - BBC News

Officials Confirm Taliban Leader's Capture - American Forces Press Service

Petraeus Denies he Thought of Quitting Afghan Post - Associated Press

Pakistan

Pakistani Militias Offer Lessons for U.S. in Afghanistan - Washington Post

Cables: U.S. Officials Struggle for Leverage in Pakistan - Washington Post

Dozens Killed in Twin Blasts in Northwest Pakistan - Voice of America

Bombings Kill Dozens in Pakistan Tribal Area - Washington Post

Bombers in Pakistan Strike Anti-Taliban Conference - New York Times

Suicide Bombers Kill 41 in Pakistan - Los Angeles Times

Official in Pakistan Escapes Assassination Bid - New York Times

Attack on Senior Pakistani Official Wounds 9 - Associated Press

U.S. Drone Attack Kills Five 'Militants' in Pakistan - BBC News

Iran

Iran Discussing Nuclear Program in Geneva - Voice of America

Nations Start Talks With Iran on Its Nuclear Program - New York Times

Nuclear Program Dominates Talks Between Iran, World Powers - Washington Post

Iran Talks Resume With No Signs of Progress - Associated Press

Iran Nuclear Talks Resume, No Breakthrough Expected - Reuters

Iran Says New Round of Nuclear Talks Agreed for Jan - BBC News

Iran Signals Willingness to Further Discuss Nuclear Program - Los Angeles Times

Iran Considers Release Of German Reporters - Reuters

Iran's Divorce Rate Stirs Fears of Society in Crisis - New York Times

Iraq

WikiLeaks Disclosures Tell of Iran's Hand in the Politics of Iraq - Washington Times

Diplomats Were Misled by Saddam's 'Cordial' Manner - Der Spiegel

Cable Reveals Details About Hussein's 'Hastily Run' Execution - CNN News

Korean Peninsula

Obama Urges China to Check North Koreans - New York Times

Pacific Commander Calls for More Chinese Influence - Associated Press

China Hits Back At Criticism Over North Korea - Reuters

Diplomatic Impasse Over Korea Peninsula Crisis - Reuters

Clinton Reaffirms Partnership With Seoul, Tokyo, Amid Concern for N.K. - VOA

S. Korea, U.S. Hold Military Talks on N. Korea - Associated Press

Mullen to Visit Seoul to Consult, Reassure Allies - American Forces Press Service

South Korean Military Starts Live-Fire Drills - Voice of America

South Korea Begins Naval Firing Drills - New York Times

S. Korea to Make Islands Near N. Korea Fortresses - Associated Press

ICC Probes Alleged North Korean War Crimes - Washington Post

War-crimes Probe Opened Against N. Korea - Washington Times

WikiLeaks

WikiLeaks, Round Three - Small Wars Journal (post-release)

SWJ Wikileaks Roundup - Small Wars Journal (pre-release)

WikiLeaks Founder Warns About More Dispatches - New York Times

WikiLeaks Ready to Release Giant 'Insurance' File if Shut Down - FOX News

Leaked Cable Lists Sensitive Sites - New York Times

U.S. Denounces Release of List of Crucial Overseas Facilities - Los Angeles Times

Assange Arrested in London - BBC News

Britain Arrests WikiLeaks Founder on Sex Charges - New York Times

Julian Assange Arrested in Sex Case - Los Angeles Times

Julian Assange to be Questioned by British Police - The Guardian

U.K.: WikiLeaks Founder Arrested - Associated Press

Assange's Legal, Financial Options Narrowing - Washington Post

Assange Becomes the U.S.'s Public Enemy No. 1 - Der Spiegel

U.S. Department of Defense

Service Members Face New Threat: Identity Theft - New York Times

Marines, Navy to Conduct Synthetic Amphibious Exercise - AFPS

Gates Skeptical of 'Don't Ask , Don't Tell' Repeal This Year - New York Times

Sailor Accused of Trying to Sell Classified Military Documents - Washington Post

United States

U.S. Attorney General Says WikiLeaks Puts Americans at Risk - Voice of America

State Dept. Daily Is Window on a Jittery Planet - New York Times

Senators Unveil anti-WikiLeaks Bill - The Hill

New START: Bombs Away - New York Times opinion

Africa

Ivory Coast Curfew Extended as Protests Continue Over Disputed Election - VOA

Standoff in Ivory Coast Leads to Fears of Violence - New York Times

Mbeki Ends Ivory Coast Poll Row Talks Without Deal - Reuters

Ivory Coast: Deadlock Leads to Food Shortages - BBC News

Nigeria Militants Say Hit Oil Pipeline In Delta - Reuters

Americas and Caribbean

Cholera Kills More Than 2,000 in Haiti - Voice of America

Haiti Waits for Election Results Amid Fraud, Chaos - Associated Press

Tense Haiti Awaits Results Of Turbulent Elections - Reuters

Peru's Humala Calls Garcia A Threat to Democracy - Reuters

Asia Pacific

China Says Does Not Want to "Replace" U.S. As World Power - Reuters

China Says It Hopes Leaks Do Not Hurt U.S. Ties - Associated Press

China to Choose Catholic Heads; Vatican Ties Tense - Associated Press

China Denounces Nobel Prize Supporters as 'Clowns' - Associated Press

19 Countries to Miss Nobel Ceremony - Associated Press

Philippines and China to Sign First Military Deal - BBC News

Filipino Troops Kill 5 Rebels Ahead of Xmas Truce - Associated Press

Senior U.S. Official Visits Burma - Associated Press

Europe

Leaked Memo Offers Insight to Russian Security Agencies - Washington Post

NATO Balanced Baltic and Russian Anxieties - New York Times

Cables Reveal Secret NATO Plans to Defend Baltics from Russia - The Guardian

Cables: Poland Wants Missile Shield to Protect Against Russia - The Guardian

Poland and Russia Vow to Open New Chapter of Cooperation - New York Times

U.N. Prosecutor Urges Faster Serbia War Crimes Action - Reuters

Ireland Feels Pain of Crisis in Its Purse and Its Soul - New York Times

Middle East

Syria, Hezbollah: U.S. Strains to Stop Arms Flow - New York Times

Election Monitors Allege Widespread Fraud in Egyptian Vote - Voice of America

Egypt's Ruling Party Sweeps Parliament Vote - Associated Press

14-Year-Old's Water Pipe Blamed for Israeli Fire - New York Times

Palestinian War Refugees Housed in 'Containers' - Washington Times

Argentina Recognizes Palestine Pre-1967 Borders - Reuters

Israel Upset at Argentina Recognition of Palestine - Associated Press

Saudi Police Arrest Reformist Writer - Associated Press

NCTC's war on terrorism is way beyond Afghanistan

Mon, 12/06/2010 - 10:06am
On December 1st, Michael Leiter, the Director of the National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC), delivered remarks and answered questions at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) (click here to view the entire event). NCTC is the U.S. government's central all-source collection point for terrorist data and intelligence. NCTC is also a principal counter-terrorism (CT) analyst and maintains the TIDE terror suspect database, produces daily CT intelligence products, and publishes a variety of CT watch-lists. The NCTC director is also one of the government's primary CT strategists.

Leiter's speech discussed the evolving terror threat and what U.S. citizens should expect from their government's CT efforts. Leiter's remarks had two themes. First, al Qaeda has transformed from a tightly controlled hierarchical organization into a highly diffuse and "headless" movement. Second, although he and his colleagues are striving mightily, Leiter warned that it will be "impossible" to prevent Islamist terrorist attacks inside the United States, especially small-scale attacks such as those experienced over the past year. Leiter recommended that the country adopt an attitude of "quiet, confident resilience" against this prospect. In his view, extravagant responses to non-existential attacks only reward the terrorists and are self-defeating. Leiter's remarks implied that the U.S. military campaign in Afghanistan is at best peripheral to his mission and at worst making his job more difficult.

According to Leiter, from 1998 to 2006, al Qaeda was a centralized organization run by its high command in Afghanistan and Pakistan. Between 2006 and 2009, a variety of al Qaeda affiliates emerged, which are now independent of the high command and pursue their own objectives with their own techniques. Since 2009, al Qaeda has evolved into its current stage which Leiter calls a "movement," or a diffuse global culture. In this movement phase, the United States must now increasingly contend with self-radicalizing homegrown terrorists.

Leiter explained that al Qaeda's transformation since 1998 has made his job enormously more difficult. He asserted that the operational tempo of his dispersed adversaries is increasing, with the past 15 months being the busiest since 2001.

Although Leiter discussed CT operations in Pakistan, Yemen, and elsewhere, not once in the nearly hour-long session did he mention the U.S. military campaign in Afghanistan and its relationship to counter-terrorism. NCTC's war against terrorism has long since moved on to many different fronts, including many inside the United States itself. Policymakers will have to ponder whether the Afghan war is now about terrorism or more about protecting America's prestige. And whether the answer to that question should have a bearing on Afghan war policy.

6 December SWJ Roundup

Mon, 12/06/2010 - 8:19am
Afghanistan

Analysis: Obama's Trip Signals Afghan War Plan Set - Associated Press

U.N. Appeals for $678 Million in Aid for Afghanistan - Associated Press

Afghan Poll Shows Falling Confidence in U.S. - Washington Post

Afghans' Faith In U.S. Ebbing, Poll Finds - Reuters

Afghan Support for Insurgency Rising, Poll Suggests - BBC News

A Look at the Method Behind the Post Afghan Poll - Washington Post

Villagers in Afghan District Told Local Government is Key - Stars and Stripes

U.S. Fights to Open School in Taliban Area - Associated Press

Afghanistan Government Arrests 4 on Election Panel - New York Times

4 More Afghan Election Employees Arrested - Associated Press

Afghan Minister Disputes U.S. Diplomatic Cable - Associated Press

Senior Official Details Success, Challenges in Afghanistan - AFPS

Attacks Kill 3 Coalition Troops in Afghanistan - Los Angeles Times

Afghanistan Blast Kills 2 NATO Troops - Voice of America

Two NATO Soldiers Killed in Suicide Attack - Agence France-Presse

Two Foreign Troops Killed in Attack - BBC News

Blast Near Afghan Military Base, Casualties - Reuters

Afghan Withdrawal Deadline Undermines Success - Washington Times opinion

Pakistan

Outlook Glum for 'Porous' Pakistan Border - Washington Times

Pakistanis Return to Tribal Area After Offensive - Associated Press

Pakistan Military Says Its Supports Government - Associated Press

Pakistan Suicide Bomb Attack Kills Dozens - BBC News

Blasts in Government Compound Kill 28 in Pakistan - Associated Press

Suicide Blasts Kill 40 In Pakistan's Northwest - Reuters

Wikileaks: Mumbai Accused 'Directs Terror from Jail' - BBC News

Pakistan Woman Recounts Ordeal Under Taliban - Associated Press

Pakistan Court Issues Warrants Over Bhutto's Death - Associated Press

Afghanistan / Pakistan

Pakistan, Afghanistan Leaders Reject Credibility of WikiLeaks Documents - VOA

Afghans and Pakistanis Attack Cables - New York Times

Korean Peninsula

U.S. Steps Up Pressure on China to Rein in N. Korea - Washington Post

China's Hu Tells Obama Korea Tension Could Go Out Of Control - Reuters

U.S., Allies, Plot North Korea Strategy Without China - Reuters

North Korea Increases Criticism of the South - Wall Street Journal

Despite Threats, War Not Likely in Korea - Stars and Stripes

South Korea Repeats Warning Against North Korea - Reuters

N. Korea Lambasts S. Korea's New Defense Chief - Associated Press

South Korea Begins Naval Firing Drills - New York Times

Haunted by Attack, Few Return to Yeonpyeong Island - New York Times

Iraq

U.S. Fears Allawi's Political Exclusion - Washington Post

Cables: Meddling Neighbors Undercut Iraq's Political Stability - New York Times

As U.S. Leaves, Iraqis Suffer Economic Toll - New York Times

More Foreign Fighters Seen Slipping Back into Iraq - Associated Press

Dozens of Casualties in Explosions Targeting Shi'ite Areas of Baghdad - VOA

7 Blasts Hit Baghdad, With Mostly Shiite Targets - New York Times

Baghdad Bombs Targeting Shiite Areas Kill 17 - Associated Press

E-mails from the Front Lines of the Iraq War - Los Angeles Times

Iran

Nuclear Talks Start Between Iran and 6 Nations - New York Times

Iran Begins Talks with World Powers Amid Low Expectations - Washington Post

Iran Announces Nuclear Breakthrough on Eve of Talks - Los Angeles Times

Iran and Key Powers Meet for Nuclear Talks in Geneva - BBC News

Iran Talks Start After Strong Rhetoric, Low Hopes - Associated Press

Major Powers, Iran Resume Nuclear Talks - Reuters

Nuclear Negotiators Seek Framework, Don't See Breakthrough - Bloomberg

Iran Tells Gulf Arabs It Is No Threat to Region - Voice of America

Iran Says U.N. Agency Sending Spies, Not Inspectors - Associated Press

Iran Says It Has Produced Its First Yellowcake Uranium - Voice of America

Iran Claims it Can Produce Yellow-cake Uranium - Los Angeles Times

Iran to Process Its Own Raw Uranium - Associated Press

Iranian Official Signals Gap Ahead of Talks - Washington Post

Gulf Leaders to Meet as Iran Nuclear Fears Loom - Associated Press

Defiant Iran Reports Nuclear Advance Before Talks - Reuters

Iran Talks: Strong Rhetoric, Low Expectations - Associated Press

Entrepreneurs do Business of a Sort in Face of Sanctions - Los Angeles Times

Iranian Cash Building Bonds with Bolivia - Washington Post

Nuclear Talks Serve Dual Purpose for Iran - Los Angeles Times opinion

WikiLeaks

WikiLeaks, Round Three - Small Wars Journal (post-release)

SWJ Wikileaks Roundup - Small Wars Journal (pre-release)

U.S. Department of Defense

3 of 4 Service Chiefs Oppose Prompt DADT Repeal - Stars and Stripes

Pentagon Lawyer Who Co-Wrote Report on Gays - New York Times

DADT: Let the Pentagon Lead - Washington Post editorial

Panel: Cowpens' CO Should Get General Discharge - Navy Times

Counterspies Hunt Russian Mole Inside NSA - Washington Times

NCIS: Sailor at Bragg Sold Secret Documents - Fayetteville Observer

United States

Sailor Remembers Pearl Harbor Attack 69 Years Ago - Associated Press

Cables Depict Range of Obama Diplomacy - New York Times

Leaked U.S. Documents Highlight Terror Fund Woes - Associated Press

From WikiLemons, Clinton Tries to Make Lemonade - New York Times

Clinton Tour Showed Limits of WikiLeaks Damage - Associated Press

Government Workers Ordered Not to Read Cables - New York Times

Tension Grows Between Calif. Muslims, FBI - Washington Post

Terrorism Makes New York More Wary, Gradually - Associated Press

Unusual Methods Helped ICE Hit Deportation Mark - Washington Post

New Subject of Debate on Mideast: Hummus - New York Times

Who had the Worst Week? Hillary Clinton - Washington Post opinion

Better Intelligence Oversight - Washington Post opinion

United Kingdom

Aide to British Lawmaker Arrested Over Spying Claims - New York Times

Africa

Egypt Says South Sudan Secession Looks Inevitable - Reuters

South Sudan Official: No Delay to Jan Freedom Vote - Associated Press

Sudan's South Rejects Bid For Delay Of January 9 Vote - Reuters

Somalia: Returning to Help Homeland - Washington Post

Bangladeshi Ship Seized by Pirates Heads to Somalia - BBC News

Somali Pirates Hijack Cargo Ship With 25 People Off India - Associated Press

Dutch to Try Five Somalis For Pirate Hijacking - Reuters

A Government Forms in Ivory Coast - New York Times

Protests in Ivory Coast After 2 Claim Presidency - Associated Press

Rival Presidential Candidates Take Dueling Oaths of Office in Ivory Coast - VOA

2 Oaths of Office Taken in Ivory Coast - New York Times

Ivory Coast: Rival Presidents Each Sworn In - Los Angeles Times

Ivory Coast Leader Takes Oath Despite Dispute - Associated Press

Ivory Coast's Gbagbo Sworn In Despite World Rejection - Reuters

Mbeki Tries to Mediate Ivory Coast Presidential Standoff - VOA

Mbeki Starts Ivory Coast Mission - BBC News

Mbeki In Ivory Coast to Mediate In Election Standoff - Reuters

E.U.: Ivory Coast Election Uncertainty Bad For Region - Reuters

Kenya Asks for FBI Help After 3 Police Killed - Associated Press

S. African Newspaper Debuts Denying It's ANC Agent - Associated Press

Western Sahara: Refugees Journey Back Home - Washington Post

Americas and Caribbean

Mexico Border Drug Tunnels Put Warehouses Under Scrutiny - Associated Press

Mexican State Will Try Boy Accused of Beheadings - Associated Press

Gunmen Kill 4 in Attack on 2 Mexico Rehab Centers - Associated Press

Mexico: Knocking Down the Kingpins - Los Angeles Times editorial

Incoming Brazilian President Wants Closer Ties With U.S. - Voice of America

Iranian Cash Building Bonds with Bolivia - Washington Post

Venezuelans Elect 11 Mayors, 2 State Governors - Associated Press

Haiti: More Cholera Cases, Fewer Deaths - Voice of Amercia

I've Seen the Future (in Haiti) - New York Times opinion

Asia Pacific

Japan Defence Plan Wary Of China's Military - Reuters

Cables Discuss Vast Hacking by a China That Fears the Web - New York Times

WikiLeaks: Chinese Leaders Ordered Google Hack - Washington Post

Hundreds in Hong Kong March for Nobel Winner's Freedom - Voice of America

Hong Kong Protest Calls for Nobel Winner's Freedom - Associated Press

Hundreds In Hong Kong Demand China Free Nobel Winner Liu - Reuters

Rights Group Says Caning in Malaysia is Torture - New York Times

Philippine Leader Says Media Ruining His Love Life - Associated Press

Europe

As Europe Cuts Military Budgets, Worry About Clout - Los Angeles Times

Germany's Angst About Islamists Goes Mainstream - Associated Press

Greece: Police Say 6 Arrests Foiled Attack - New York Times

Greek Police Find Suspected Guerrilla Arms Cache - Reuters

Greek Gun Hideouts 'Probed for Extremist Links' - Agence France-Presse

Russia Reports $3.8 Trillion In Suspect Transfers - Reuters

IMF to urge E.U. to Shore Up Bailout Fund - Washington Post

Cables: Europe Wary of U.S. Bank Monitors - New York Times

Russia: Mr. Putin's Show Trial - Washington Post editorial

Europe's Piecemeal Failure - New York Times opinion

Is Turkey Still an Ally? - Washington Post opinion

Middle East

Cables Suggest Mideast Resists Cutting Terrorists' Cash - New York Times

Wikileaks: Saudis 'Chief Funders of al-Qaeda' - Daily Telegraph

Gates Meets With Leaders in Oman, Plans Carrier Visit - AFPS

Gates Visits Oman; Iran, Yemen on Agenda - Associated Press

Abbas Threatens to Dissolve Palestinian Authority - Voice of America

Abbas: Last Resort I'll Ask Israel to Take Over - Associated Press

Israel Fears 'Flood' of Migrants Threatens State - Associated Press

Israel Credits Outside Help as Deadly Fire Is Contained - New York Times

Suspects Held as Deadly Fire Rages in Israel for Third Day - New York Times

Israeli Police Say Negligence Likely Caused Blaze - Associated Press

U.N. Investigating Reported Device Blast in Lebanon - Associated Press

Yemen Loses in Soccer, but Scores a P.R. Victory - New York Times

Polls in Egyptian Runoff Close Under Protest - Voice of America

Low Interest in Egyptian Runoff That Favors Ruling Party - New York Times

Egypt Holds Parliament Runoffs Amid Fraud Claims - Associated Press

Egyptians Vote In Run-Off After Opposition Quits - Reuters

Hosni Mubarak Party to Sail Through Boycotted Egypt Vote - Reuters

Why is the U.S. Afraid of Egypt? - Washington Post editorial

Israel and the U.S.: A Lopsided Relationship - Los Angeles Times opinion

South Asia

Pakistani Hackers Shut India Crime Bureau Website - Reuters

'Pak Cyber Army' Claims Credit for CBI Website Attack - Times of India

Sarkozy Courts Indian Business, G20 Support - Reuters

India, France Sign Multimillion Nuclear Power Deal - Associated Press

Sri Lankan War Crimes Suspect Posted to U.N. - Washington Times