Small Wars Journal

SWJ Book Review – Planning to Fail: The US Wars in Vietnam, Afghanistan, and Iraq

Fri, 10/01/2021 - 6:19pm

SWJ Book Review – Planning to Fail: The US Wars in Vietnam, Afghanistan, and Iraq

Nathan P. Jones

PTF

James H. Lebovic. Planning to Fail: The US Wars in Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan. New York: Oxford University Press. 2019. [ISBN: 978-0-19-093532-0, Hardcover, 246 pages]

As we reel from the United States’ precipitous and messy withdrawal from Afghanistan, there is no better time to look back at the unsung works that predicted this possibility years prior and assess other lessons from those works. One such work is Lebovic’s Planning to Fail; a prescient practical/academic treatise on three of the United States’ great foreign policy blunders. I say prescient because it predicted many of the failures of the Afghanistan campaign and speaks to the pain and analysis, we all went through in August and September of 2021. Certainly, Biden bears blame at first blanche.  Then as we think back, we assign blame to Trump, to Obama, to Bush. Regardless of party, there was a structural rot to the foundation of the enterprise. Lebovic lays out exactly what that was, and in doing so, provides a framework of thought that if properly applied could help us to avoid the quagmires that have become features (not bugs) of US foreign policy interventions.

I met Professor James Lebovic of George Washington University as a doctoral candidate in 2009 at the University of California, Irvine where I was a discussant for a Spring 2009 Research in International Global Studies (RIGS) talk on his earlier book The Limits of US Military Capability: Lessons from Vietnam and Iraq.[1] The chapter we focused on was on the limitations of the United States to “leverage” host governments.  As a graduate student studying counterinsurgency (COIN) in the mid 2000s I found this example of the principal-agent problem helpful in my thinking on US COIN failures and successes. Full disclosure: I am thanked in the acknowledgements of his 2010 book. In 2019 Lebovic published Planning to Fail building off his earlier work. 

Planning to Fail is a well-structured comparison of three cases: Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan with summative Introduction and Conclusion chapters. This book is particularly well-suited for Small Wars Journal readers given their familiarity with the case studies which are the bread and butter of US COIN studies. The cases are analyzed with a unified structure assessing useful, but insufficient cognitive bias explanations in the literature, and Lebovic’s four phases which include: Stage 1: (The decision to intervene) with a ‘fixation’ on mission goals, stage 2: a ‘disjunction’ between the military means and ends, stage 3: ‘resource limitation’ or ‘constriction’ (the war has become expensive and spending caps are needed) and stage 4: disengagement of military forces (‘time constraints’ for exit).  In each case study chapter, he takes us through the insufficiency of other explanations, and through the four phases.  The chapters run long ranging from about 47 pages (Vietnam) to 62 pages (Afghanistan) with the middle Iraq chapter splitting the difference.  This weakness is at once exacerbated and mitigated by neat summaries of the overarching argument in the conclusion of each chapter, which allows the book to be skimmed by the pressed for time (doctoral students). 

Vietnam

Lebovic argues, President Johnson could have taken any position on Vietnam and a plausible argument for rationality could have been made ex post facto. This clarity demonstrated the insufficiency of the rationality arguments explaining the US entry into Vietnam. 

In ‘stage 1 fixation’ the Johnson administration fixated on military solution first by air (Operation Rolling Thunder) then by ground invasion. It failed to rigorously question its own goals focusing on the tactical over the strategic. In stage 2 ‘disjunction’ the Administration intended to use “bombing” for “coercive effect,” but the signaling was lost in the “noise” of “unintended messages sent by military and practical constraints on bombing.”(pp. 61-62) The administration limited bombing to avoid the entry of the Chinese or Soviets into the conflict. 

In stage 3 limitation and constriction “Johnson ruled out a troop increase and an escalation or expansion of the conflict.” Johnson fixated on the “middle option” neither escalating nor withdrawing. In stage IV ‘extrication’ or ‘disengagement’ became the goal. Under the Nixon administration the war expanded, but for the purpose of a stronger US negotiating position, de-Americanization, and Vietnamization of the war effort. The goal of “peace with honor” was defined to fit the Nixon administration’s desire to leave the conflict. Saigon ultimately fell in 1975 as the South Vietnamese military and government with no US funding or support ultimately collapsed. “The neglected political dimension of the war would ultimately prove decisive.”(pp. 62-63)

Iraq

The Bush Administration fixated on regime change in Iraq, but failed to plan for the aftermath including the insurgency and provision of public security. In stage 2 the Bush Administration refused to acknowledge the militia and insurgency problem within the country. It failed to think through policies like de-Baathification and the disbanding of the Iraqi Army. 

In stage III resources were “constricted,” though Lebovic has some explaining to do in that this was the period of the troop surge 2007 and the pivot to counterinsurgency.  He describes this as actually consistent with the constriction phase because this was the “least costly option” and was small and “short term.”(p. 117) In stage 4, the Obama administration pushed a negotiating position on the status of forces that effectively guaranteed an exit in 2011. Lebovic rightly argues this was more about extricating the US from Iraq by pointing out that when the United States reentered Iraq later in combat against the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS), the Iraqi government easily accepted the status of US forces not being judicially subject to Iraqi law. 

Afghanistan

Planning to Fail saves its longest substantive chapter for Afghanistan the most recent continuing US large scale intervention.  When I say that Lebovic’s work is prescient, consider that the following was published in 2019 and likely written well before that given academic timetables:

The risk, of course, was that Afghan Security forces, despite their infusions of funds would become a “work in regress.”  They could well disintegrate or collapse, perhaps in a slow yet accelerating downward spiral.  As security conditions deteriorated, all involved might fend for themselves—by cutting and running, grabbing what benefits they could, or making deals—allowing the Taliban to press its advantages. Pulling from its (now over two decades old) playbook, the Taliban could establish itself in the hospitable southern and eastern portions of the country and eventually move to envelop the rest.(p. 172)

Does that feel familiar given the events of 2021? I am interested in the “making deals” aspect of the fall.  Much has been said about “intelligence failure” on the fall, but the issue was not that the Afghan government and Army would fall as many predicted that, but how fast. One day we woke up and the head of Kabul’s police was working with the Taliban and as contemporaneous reporting argued, this could not have happened without advanced planning. This reminded me of my own research on Mexican drug trafficking organizations and how they take over new territories.  They send emissaries to meet with local cell leaders and get the locals to defect to the invading organization.[2] On the ground this has the effect of an overnight takeover with surprising speed and is reminiscent of the Sun Tzu quote “for to win one hundred victories in one hundred battles is not the acme of skill. To subdue the enemy without fighting is supreme excellence.”[3]

Recommendations for Future Policymakers

Lebovic’s Planning to Fail, provides eight recommendations that center on clear thinking about initiating interventions and the decision-making process. They include: 1) recognizing that “assessment is a continuous process;” 2) avoid ad hoc vague argumentation such as the US credibility argument in Vietnam; 3) get all of government on the same page, lest there be mission creep; 4) avoid “temporizing” delaying decisions can limit options; 5) “regularize” contingency planning for potential failure, 6) US must understand limitations including the ability to leverage host governments through support or threats of withdrawal, 7) reverse the decision making process by considering alterative futures; 8) “policy makers must remain wary of the non-decision.”(p. 192) This is a useful checklist for policy makers to evaluate foreign intervention decisions. Two of them have significant overlap (6) temporizing and (8) non-decision are both related to the timing of decision making and the desire to avoid painful decisions.  Recommendation 7 on considering alterative futures deserved a bit more fleshing out as there are many forecasting methodologies that could be recommended, though this might require its own treatise.[4] Lebovic’s Planning to Fail provides its readers with clear case studies, a useful four phase framework, and policy recommendations to address how policy makers approach these decisions. 

Endnotes

[1] James H. Lebovic. The Limits of US Military Capability: Lessons from Vietnam and Iraq. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2010.

[2] Nathan P. Jones. “Bacterial Conjugation as a Framework for the Homogenization of Tactics in Mexican Organized Crime.” Studies in Conflict & Terrorism. Vol. 44, no. 10. 2021: pp. 855-884, https://doi.org/10.1080/1057610X.2019.1586356.

[3] Tao Hanzhang, Sun Tzu’s Art of War: The Modern Chinese Interpretation, trans. Yuan Shibing. New York: Sterling Publishing Company, 2000, p. 33.

[4] See Sarah Miller Beebe and Randolph H. Pherson, Cases in Intelligence Analysis: Structured Analytic Techniques in Action. Thousand Oaks: CQ Press, 2014; Andy Hines and Peter C. Bishop, “Framework Foresight: Exploring Futures the Houston Way,” Futures Vol. 51. 29 May 2013: 31–49; Randolph H. Pherson and Richards J. Heuer Jr. Structured Analytic Techniques for Intelligence Analysis, 3rd ed. Thousand Oaks: Sage, 2019.

Categories: SWJ Book Review

About the Author(s)

Dr. Nathan P. Jones is an Associate Professor of Security Studies at Sam Houston State University and a Non-resident Scholar for Rice University’s Baker Institute in Drug Policy and Mexico Studies; he previously was an Alfred C. Glassell III Postdoctoral Fellow in Drug Policy at Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy. He holds a PhD from the University of California, Irvine and won an Institute for Global Conflict and Cooperation Fellowship to conduct fieldwork in Mexico on organized crime. Jones published Mexico's Illicit Drug Networks and the State Reaction (Georgetown University Press, 2016), and has published with numerous think tanks and peer reviewed journals. He is a Small Wars Journal–El Centro Senior Fellow and serves as the book review editor for the Journal of Strategic Security.

 

 

Comments

Dominikas22

Thu, 03/02/2023 - 2:38pm

seobureau

Thu, 02/09/2023 - 3:07am

7s Model

About Blank

AB Testing

Acquisitie

Adaptief

AdBlock

Adobe Flash

Advertorial

Affect Heuristic

Affiliate Marketing

Ahrefs

Aida Model

Algoritme

Ambassadeur

AMP

Animatie

Ansoff Matrix

Apenstaartje

API

Apple Adverteren

Applicatie

App Store

Assortiment

Audacity

Augmented Reality

Autoritair

B2B

B2B Marketing

Bait and switch

Banner

BCG Matrix

Benchmarking

Bestand

Bid

Bing Ads

Bitcoin

Blokchain

Blogger

Branded Content

Branding

Breadcrumbs

Break Even Point

Briefing

Bucket List

Bureau

Business Casual

Business Intelligence

Business Model

Call To Action

Camtasia

Canonical

Canvas Model

Captcha

Case Study

C Block

Character Count

Chatbots

Churn Rate Betekenis

Cialdini

Clickbait

Clicks

CMS

Cohorten

Comment

Comfort Zone

Communicatie

Community

Conceptstore

Concurrentieanalyse

Consent

Consultancy

Content Gap

Contentstrategie

Conversational AI

Conversie Optimalisatie

Cookies verwijderen Chrome

Copywriter

Cost Per Acquisition

CPC Adverteren

CPL

CPM

Cost Per Sale

Crawlen

Cross Selling

Crowdfunding

Crowdsourcing

Cryptocurrency

CTR

Customer Intimacy

Customer Journey

Customer Lifetime Value

Customer Service

Data Management

Decision Making Unit

Deeplink

Deskresearch

Detachering

SEO Diensten

Alle bedrijven

Content Marketing

Conversie

E-mail Marketing

Facebook Adverteren

Internet Adverteren

Onsite SEO

Optimalisatie

Pay Per Click

Pay Per Click Optimalisatie

Professionele SEO Diensten

SEO consult

SEO copywriting

Sociale Media

Web Ontwikkeling

Web Statistieken

Webteksten

Zoekmachine Adverteren

Zoekmachine Optimalisatie

Zoekmachine Marketing

Digitaal Marketing Bureau

Discounter

Display Advertising

DMP

DNS Server

Doelgroepanalyse

Domeinnaam

Doubleclick

DRM

Dropshipping

Drupal

DuckDuckGo

Early Adopters

E-A-T

e Commerce

Elevator Pitch

Embargo

Engagement

Ephemeral

Error 404

Etalage

Evergreen Content

Evernote

Extensie

Extranet

Facebook Ads

Facebook Debugger

Facebook Pixel

FAQ

Favicon

Fear Of Missing Out

Fee

Feed

Firebase

Footer

Fotoshop

Framework

Frequentie

FTP

Funnel

FYI

Garantie

Gamification

GDPR

Generatie Z

Gerelateerde

Geschiedenis wissen Google

Ghostwriter

Golden Circle

Google Account

Google Ads

Google Adsense

AdWords

Google Afbeeldingen

Google Agenda

Google Alerts

Google Analytics

Google Assistent

Google Attribution

Google Cache

Google Dashboard

Google Data Studio

Google Express

Google Fonts

Google Forms

Google Home

Google Hoofdkantoor

Google Lens

Google Maps Streetview

Google Mobiele Index

Google Nieuws

Google.nl Geschiedenis Ontstaan Oprichters

Google Optimize

Google Partners

Google Places

Google Plus

Google Scholar

Google Search

Google Shopping

Google Sitemap

Google Tag Manager

Google Toolbar

Google Trends

Google Vertalen

Google Video

Google Wifi

Gratis Muziek Downloaden

Gravatar

Growth Hacking

Guerilla Marketing

Guido Marchal

h2

Halo Effect

Hangouts

Hashtag

Header

Heatmaps

HIPPO

Hit

Homepage

Hootsuite

Hotjar

Htaccess redirect

HTML5

HTTPS Google

HTTP Statuscode 200

HTTP Statuscode 301

HTTP Statuscode 302

Huisstijl

Hummingbird

Hypotheekrente

Hypothese

iBeacon

ICT

iFrame

Illustratie

IM

Impressie

InDesign

Influencer Marketing

Infographic

Innovatie

Instagram Adverteren

Internet Explorer

Internet Marketing

Internet Marketing Bureau

Internet of things

Javascript

Joint Venture

Joomla

JPG

Kernwaarden

Keyword

Keyword Hero

Keyword Tool

Klanttevredenheid

KPI

Kunstmatige Intelligentie

Kwaliteit

Landing Page

Landscape

Laravel

Lead Generation

Linkbuilding

Linked In

Logo

Lorem Ipsum

Magento 2

MailChimp

Mailserver

Malwarebytes

Marge

Marketing Automation

Marketing Bureau

Marketingmix

Marketingplan

Marketingstrategie

Marketplace

Marktaandeel

Material Design

Maturity model

Media Expert

Memes

Merchant Center

Messenger

Meta Description

Millenials

MKB

Mobile Marketing

Moodboard

MSN Hotmail

MySpace

Narrowcasting

Net Promoter Score

Neural Matching

Neuromarketing

NFC

Niche

Nieuwe Media

No Cure No Pay

Node js

Nofollow

Noindex

Off-site SEO

Omnichannel

Omzet

On Demand

Online Marketing Noord-Holland

Online Marketing Zuid-Holland

Online Marketeer

Online Marketing

Online Marketing Bureau

Online Marketing Vacatures

Optimizely

Organigram

Outsourcing

Pagerank

Parallax

Parameters

Payment Service Provider

Pay Per Click Marketing

Pay Per View

PDF

Peer to Peer

Penguin

Persona

Personal Branding

Personalisatie

Persoonlijk

Pingdom Tools

Pinterest Adverteren

Piwik

Pixlr

Placeholder

Plagiaat

Podcast

Pogo-sticking

Point Of View

Poll

Portrait

Positionering

Potentiële

Privacy

Productfotografie

Product Owner

Product Placement

Prognose

Profielfoto

Programmtic trading

Progressive Web App

Propositie

Prospect

Protocol

Provider

Public Relations

QR Code

Quick Wins

Queue

RankBrain

Realtime

Redigeren

Retail

Retargeting

Retourneren

Reviews

RGB

Rich Snippets

ROAS

Robots txt

ROI

RSS

RSS feed

SaaS

Sandbox

Scope

Score

Scrum Master

Script

SEA

Search Engine Optimization

See Think Do Care

Segmentatie

Selfie

SEM

Semantiek

SEO

SEO Check

SEO Checklist

SEO Expert

SEO Kosten

SEO opleiding

SEO optimalisatie

SEOShop

SEO tips

SERP

Service Level Agreement

SERVQUAL

Sitemap WordPress

SKU

Slider

Smart Doelen

SMS

Snapchat Adverteren

Social Media

Spam

Specialist

Speedtest

Spellingscontrole

Splash Page

Sponsoring

Spotify Adverteren

Startpagina

Status Quo

Stockfoto's

Storytelling

Subcategorieen

Swot Analyse

Synergie

Tag

Tag Manager

Template

Testimonial

Third Party Cookies

Time Management

Tinder Adverteren

Tone of Voice Voorbeelden

Tor Netwerk

Touchpoints

Traffic

Trends

Trigger

Tumbr

Tweetdeck

Twitter

URL

URL Shortener

Usability

User Experience

User Stories

USP

UTC Tijd

UTM

Vacatures

Vacatures HTML Specialist

Vactures Software Designer

Value Proposition

Verdienmodel

Vimeo

Viral Marketing

Virtual Reality

Visitekaartje

Vlogger

Voice Search

W3C

Warenhuis

Wat betekent

Wat betekent above the fold

Wat betekent ajax

Wat betekent algoritme

Wat betekent algoritme update

Wat betekent alt attribute

Wat betekent analytics

Wat betekent anchor text

Wat betekent autoriteit

Wat betekent b2b

Wat betekent b2c

Wat betekent baidu

Wat betekent bing

Wat betekent black box

Wat betekent black hat

Wat betekent blog

Wat betekent bounce rate

Wat betekent branded keyword

Wat betekent breadcrumb

Wat betekent cache

Wat betekent canonical url

Wat betekent cctld

Wat betekent click bait

Wat betekent click-through rate

Wat betekent cloaking

Wat betekent cms

Wat betekent gebroken link

Wat is een baseline

Wat is een editorial

Wat is een metafoor

Wat is mijn IP adres

Wat is Year To Date

Wayback Machine

Wearables

Webdesign

Webmail Online

Webmaster

Webmaster Tools

Webshop

Website

Website Laten Maken

Website Migratie Checklist

Wederkerigheid

Welkom

WeTransfer

WhatsApp Business

Whitepaper

Widget

Winst

Wireframe

Wixsite

WooCommerce

WordPress

WordPress Cursus

Workflow

Yahoo Answers

Yammer

Year over Year

Yield Management

Yoast

YouTube Adverteren

YouTube Muziek

Zoekmachine Marketing Bureau

Zoekmachines

Zoekopdracht

Zoekresultaten

Zoekwoorden
 

LucindaLeidig

Sun, 10/17/2021 - 6:53am

Lives to have fun with friends, and not every student can afford a fun life due to a lot of homework, but the essay service on Grademiners helps me a lot, and it's insanely cool