First, the Good News…
I read with great interest Michael Phillips’ Wall Street Journal piece – In Counterinsurgency Class, Soldiers Think Like Taliban – as well as several e-mails concerning what is right and what is wrong with the Army’s new Afghanistan Counterinsurgency Academy.
From the WSJ article:
… Six years into the Afghan war, the Army has decided its troops on the ground still don’t understand well enough how to battle the Taliban insurgency. So since the spring, groups of 60 people have been attending intensive, five-day sessions in plywood classrooms in the corner of a U.S. base here, where they learn to think like a Taliban and counterpunch like a politician.
The academy’s principal message: The war that began to oust a regime has evolved into a popularity contest where insurgents and counterinsurgents vie for public support and the right to rule. The implicit critique: Many U.S. and allied soldiers still arrive in the country well-trained to kill, but not to persuade.
In April, the Army gave a 26-year-old Rhodes scholar, Capt. Dan Helmer, six weeks to get the school up and running. Capt. Helmer tells his students, who rank as high as colonel, that the important battles here are 80% political and just 20% military. He exhorts them to go to great lengths to understand local politics, culture and history, to make sure actions they take on the battlefield help convince Afghans that the Kabul government will serve and protect them…
For a synopsis of the good and the bad please see Ad-hockery in Afghanistan by SWJ‘s COIN counterparts and partners in crime (Charlie and AM) over at Abu Muqawama. An excerpt:
The Wall Street Jounal has a long and excellent article about the COIN Academy in Afghanistan. Establishing tactical schools in-country is a well known COIN best practice (the Jungle Warfare School in Malaya is perhaps the best known amongst COIN scholars). And, as part of our steep learning curve in Iraq and Afghanistan, we have put together such schools in both countries…
This no knock on Capt. Dan Helmer–the 26 year old Army captain and Rhode Scholar tasked with setting up the Academy. (Your faithful bloggers have benefitted from many email exchanges with him, and they all share a common mentor in fellow West Point Rhodie, LTC John Nagl.)
But, as he’ll tell you, he’s a freaking Army captain. Charlie is quite certain that Capt. Helmer is among the best and the brightest, but he’s not among those who can get @^*% done in the Army (or Afghanistan). If we were serious about such things, we might assign someone with a bit more institutional clout. Someone who could get paper copies of FM 3-24 for the Academy (it’s cool, the Army posts them online. The students just wait 47 hours to download them over what passes for an internet connection in Kabul). Someone who could actually institutionalize the Academy within the Army instead of it being a Frankenstein science project dreamed up by folks who’ve read ATOM one too many times.
We can’t win the war without places like the COIN Academy and officers like Capt. Helmer. But we also can’t do it with them alone…
