It takes two separate and independent user accounts to access all of Small Wars Journal:
Existing Council users as of August 3, 2011 have their Council Username reserved or parked as an SWJ Username. Here's how to retrieve it.
We encourage new users to sign up on both sides of the site (SWJ Main and Council) with the same username and manually maintain the two accounts in parallel. Unfortunately, we don’t (yet?) have the system linkages to take care of that for you automatically.
Access to the Journal, SWJ Blog, and other section of the main site is now controlled by a new SWJ Username. More info here. Registration is still free and easy, but it is a separate registration from the Council. Registered SWJ users can comment on all items as before, and can now rate items (1-5 stars). Comment replies are now threaded, and users can flag inappropriate comments.
There have been no changes to the Small Wars Council discussion board. It is still alive and well as a separate section of the site, with access via your Council Username.
Short answer: the one for the part of the site you're in.
Longer answer: you are welcome to sign up for either or both areas of the site. We encourage you to register simultaneously on both sides of the house using the same username. That quickly gains and maintains a consistent, ubiquitous online presence here in what we hope becomes a favored stomping ground.
You need to be logged in with your Council Username in the discussion board (make posts and new threads, view privileged forums, etc.) and with your SWJ Username to make comments on the SWJ Blog and Journal.
The social, messaging, and community features are much more fully developed and implemented now on the Council (vBulletin) side; if you want to lean in to any of those, that side might be a better bet. But we do have some minimal but eminently usable messaging and profile features on the main site (Drupal) side, so it is players’ choice.
The two parts of the site run on different software; both are best-of-breed packages, but they are not integrated (yet). There is, at present, no ongoing linkage between the two sections so any synchronization of account information is manual.We hope to integrate the separate sections’ logins, profiles, messaging, subscriptions, and all that username-related stuff in the future and are pursuing that path before we try to steroid up the new main minimal site profile functionality. All we need is money, time, and skill (pick two).
There aren't any notable changes to registration or login in the Council.
If you are an OpenID user, once you establish an SWJ Username you can link it to your OpenID account via your user profile.
We no longer recognize the old TypeKey authentication option for SWJ Blog comments.
When we went live with the new software in the main site area, we created clone SWJ Usernames for all users in good standing in the Small Wars Council. This reserved your existing Council username for you as an SWJ Username; you can activate it by using your your Council username or registered email on the SWJ password recovery page.
More detailed instructions to recover your parked username and activate it as a new SWJ Username:
If you are getting an Access Denied error message, please review this page for how to clean up our lingering mistake.
The reservation of your Council username will not expire, so there is no rush to activate it as an SWJ Username. There is no linkage between the two usernames other than the one-time parking of your existing username under your registered email; you will have two parallel accounts with identical usernames in separate systems. Once you activate the accounts, we suggest you maintain them in parallel for things like your password and registered email, but there is no requirement for that and no automatic synchronization between the two.
We realize that is a PITA at best and hopelessly confusing at worst, but it is the best we can do for now with what we've got. Again, please note this basically clones your Council Username as a valid, active and SEPARATE account for the new sections of our site.