Small Wars Journal

Afghanistan: The Empire Stopper

Tue, 08/29/2017 - 11:27am

Afghanistan: The Empire Stopper by Rod Nordland - New York Times

When the American author James A. Michener went to Afghanistan to research his work of historical fiction, “Caravans,” it was 1955 and there were barely any roads in the country. Yet there were already Americans and Russians there, jockeying for influence. Later, the book’s Afghan protagonist would tell an American diplomat that one day both America and Russia would invade Afghanistan, and that both would come to regret it.

Michener’s foresight was uncanny, but perhaps that is not terribly surprising. Afghanistan has long been called the “graveyard of empires” - for so long that it is unclear who coined that disputable term.

In truth, no great empires perished solely because of Afghanistan. Perhaps a better way to put it is that Afghanistan is the battleground of empires. Even without easily accessible resources, the country has still been blessed - or cursed, more likely - with a geopolitical position that has repeatedly put it in someone or other’s way.

In the 19th century there was the Great Game, when the British and Russian empires faced off across its forbidding deserts and mountain ranges. At the end of the 20th century it was the Cold War, when the Soviet and American rivalry played out here in a bitter guerrilla conflict. And in this century, it is the War on Terror, against a constantly shifting Taliban insurgency, with President Trump promising a renewed military commitment.

Wars of the last three “empires” to invade Afghanistan coincided with the age of photography, leaving a rich record of their triumphs and failures, and an arresting chronicle of a land that seems to have changed little in the past two centuries…

Read on.



Thu, 08/31/2017 - 11:50am

I always find it peculiar when left wing writers constantly refer to any US military action taken abroad as a matter of the Empire. President Trump has done two things clearly different than his anti-American Empire predecessor. President Trump notes as fact the existence of radical Islam. And while Mattis is trying to sort out if the stats admitting 2,000 plus transgenders of nearly 1.5 million service troops are already serving in the Armed Forces and how to proceed, President Trump has declared Afghanistan will not be allowed to become a bastion for Al-Qaeda's the Islamic State and other threats to the USA that resulted in the deaths of more Americans on 9-11 than transgenders serving in the military.