Member Login Become a Member
Advertisement

When to Leave Iraq

  |  
06.19.2008 at 12:36am

When to Leave Iraq by Colin H. Kahl and William E. Odom, Foreign Affairs, July/August 2008.

In “The Price of the Surge” (May/June 2008), Steven Simon correctly observes that the Sunni turn against al Qaeda in Iraq (AQI), known as the Sunni Awakening, has been a key factor in security progress during the period of “the surge.” Simon is also on point when he notes that the Awakening, which began before the surge, was not a direct consequence of additional US troops. But although Simon gets much of the past right, he ultimately draws the wrong lessons for US policy moving forward.

Rather than unilaterally and unconditionally withdrawing from Iraq and hoping that the international community will fill the void and push the Iraqis toward accommodation — a very unlikely scenario — the United States must embrace a policy of “conditional engagement.” This approach would couple a phased redeployment of combat forces with a commitment to providing residual support for the Iraqi government if and only if it moves toward genuine reconciliation. Conditional engagement — rather than Simon’s policy of unconditional disengagement — would incorporate the real lesson from the Sunni Awakening…

Simon provides a brilliant analysis of Iraq’s political realities, past and present, exposing the effects of the U.S. occupation. Sadly, neither the administration nor all but a few outside analysts foresaw them. More recently, most media reporting has wholly ignored the political dynamics of the new “surge” tactic. And peripatetic experts in Washington regularly return from their brief visits to Iraq to assure the public that it is lowering violence but fail to explain why. They presume that progress toward political consolidation has also been occurring, or soon will be. Instead, as Simon explains, political regression has resulted, a “retribalization” of the same nature as that which both the British colonial rulers and the Baathist Party tried to overcome in order to create a modern state in Iraq.

This should hardly come as a surprise. The history of tribalism in Iraq is well known. When the United States replaced the British in the Middle East after World War II, it set “stability” above all other interests there, maintaining it through a regional balance of power. President Bush’s invasion of Iraq broke radically with this half-century-old strategy. The prospects of success, as Simon shows, were worse than poor…

When to Leave Iraq

About The Author

Article Discussion: