Small Wars Journal

Trump Called Bergdahl a 'Dirty, Rotten Traitor,' Now a Judge Has to Decide if it Matters

Trump Called Bergdahl a 'Dirty, Rotten Traitor,' Now a Judge Has to Decide if it Matters by Corey Dickstein, Stars & Stripes

Attorneys for Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl will spar with Army prosecutors Monday over disparaging comments about the accused deserter made by President Donald Trump on the campaign trail and whether they will have an impact on the soldier’s ability to receive a fair trial.

Trump made more than 60 negative references to Bergdahl during public campaign rallies and speeches between June 2014 and August 2016, calling the former Taliban captive “a dirty, rotten traitor” and opining that he should be executed or sent back to his captors. Army judge, Col. Jeffery R. Nance, will have to decide whether those statements by Trump before he was elected president of the United States could affect the soldier’s court-martial.

Bergdahl’s attorneys said they will argue Nance must dismiss the case in its entirety because Trump’s comments denied the sergeant his right to due process and they amounted to unlawful command influence, because the commander in chief has made it clear that he wants the soldier punished. Prosecutors, in court documents filed this week, wrote Trump’s comments have no impact on Bergdahl’s ability to receive a fair trial and argue the case cannot be dismissed over statements made by a private citizen, even if that individual later becomes president…

Read on.



Sat, 02/11/2017 - 10:54am

The first thing that popped in my head after reading this headline? "Takes one to know one."