Small Wars Journal

Generals Should be Guided by Truth, Not Politics

Wed, 01/13/2010 - 6:52am
Generals Should be Guided by Truth, Not Politics - Lawrence J. Korb, Washington Post opinion.

In his Dec. 27 column, ["An admiral who found the center," op-ed], David Ignatius distorts the proper role of the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. He glosses over Adm. Mike Mullen's professional failures, particularly on Afghanistan and his handling of the firing of Gen. David McKiernan. Ignatius is wrong to argue that any military officer, especially a member of the Joint Chiefs, is supposed to find the center of the political spectrum. An officer has a responsibility to give the president and Congress his or her best military advice, whether that is embraced by the right or the left, whether it is popular or unpopular...

What about Mullen? In late 2007, when Congress asked him about the deteriorating situation in Afghanistan, Mullen shrugged it off. "In Afghanistan, we do what we can. In Iraq, we do what we must," he told the House Armed Services Committee. Was that his professional opinion, or was it the policy of President George W. Bush, who gave short shrift to Afghanistan because of his obsession with Iraq? Is that what the combatant commanders were telling him? The answer is no...

More at The Washington Post.

Comments

Bob Sykes (not verified)

Wed, 01/13/2010 - 9:30am

High-ranking generals and admirals have always been fully paid up members of the Washington political class and always will be. It is insanity to expect them to speak publically in any way that is not the politically correct cant of the moment.