Bookmark and Share
Support your
friendly 501(c)(3)


Blogroll

« November 2007 | Main | January 2008 »

December 2007 Archives

December 1, 2007

1 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

The Looking Glass War in Iraq – Victor Davis Hanson, National Review
Sovereign Impunity Wall Street Journal editorial
Osama's New Nonsense - New York Post editorial
Saudi Arabia: Modern Times, Medieval Justice - Chicago Tribune editorial
Teddy Bear Barbarism in Sudan - New York Daily News editorial
Sudan: Mobs Rule and Bullies Dictate - David Warren, Ottawa Citizen
The Africanization of the Balkans – Denis Boyles, National Review
Kosovo Stumbling to Independence - Zoran Pajic, Guardian
After Annapolis – Ariel Cohen, Washington Times
Will Peace Cost Me My Home? - Ghada Ageel, Los Angeles Times
Missing, but Not Forgotten - Leonard Stern, Ottawa Citizen
The Price of Annapolis – Lee Smith, Weekly Standard
Saying No to ChavezNew York Times editorial
Why I Parted Ways with Chavez – Raul Isaias Baduel, New York Times
Putting Chavez to a Vote? – Jaime Daremblum, National Review
Sowing Chaos in Latin America - Carlos Sabino, Washington Times
Hugo Choice – Gustavo Coronel, National Review
Venezuela's Big Mess? - William Ratliff, Houston Chronicle
The Powers of PutinLondon Daily Telegraph editorial
A Vote that Putin Fears – Marsha Lipman, Washington Post
An Improvement on Democracy – Peter Watson, London Times

Continue reading "1 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

First, the Good News…

I read with great interest Michael Phillips’ Wall Street Journal piece - In Counterinsurgency Class, Soldiers Think Like Taliban - as well as several e-mails concerning what is right and what is wrong with the Army's new Afghanistan Counterinsurgency Academy.

From the WSJ article:

... Six years into the Afghan war, the Army has decided its troops on the ground still don't understand well enough how to battle the Taliban insurgency. So since the spring, groups of 60 people have been attending intensive, five-day sessions in plywood classrooms in the corner of a U.S. base here, where they learn to think like a Taliban and counterpunch like a politician.
The academy's principal message: The war that began to oust a regime has evolved into a popularity contest where insurgents and counterinsurgents vie for public support and the right to rule. The implicit critique: Many U.S. and allied soldiers still arrive in the country well-trained to kill, but not to persuade.
In April, the Army gave a 26-year-old Rhodes scholar, Capt. Dan Helmer, six weeks to get the school up and running. Capt. Helmer tells his students, who rank as high as colonel, that the important battles here are 80% political and just 20% military. He exhorts them to go to great lengths to understand local politics, culture and history, to make sure actions they take on the battlefield help convince Afghans that the Kabul government will serve and protect them...

For a synopsis of the good and the bad please see Ad-hockery in Afghanistan by SWJ’s COIN counterparts and partners in crime (Charlie and AM) over at Abu Muqawama. An excerpt:

The Wall Street Jounal has a long and excellent article about the COIN Academy in Afghanistan. Establishing tactical schools in-country is a well known COIN best practice (the Jungle Warfare School in Malaya is perhaps the best known amongst COIN scholars). And, as part of our steep learning curve in Iraq and Afghanistan, we have put together such schools in both countries…
This no knock on Capt. Dan Helmer--the 26 year old Army captain and Rhode Scholar tasked with setting up the Academy. (Your faithful bloggers have benefitted from many email exchanges with him, and they all share a common mentor in fellow West Point Rhodie, LTC John Nagl.)
But, as he'll tell you, he's a freaking Army captain. Charlie is quite certain that Capt. Helmer is among the best and the brightest, but he's not among those who can get @^*% done in the Army (or Afghanistan). If we were serious about such things, we might assign someone with a bit more institutional clout. Someone who could get paper copies of FM 3-24 for the Academy (it's cool, the Army posts them online. The students just wait 47 hours to download them over what passes for an internet connection in Kabul). Someone who could actually institutionalize the Academy within the Army instead of it being a Frankenstein science project dreamed up by folks who've read ATOM one too many times.
We can't win the war without places like the COIN Academy and officers like Capt. Helmer. But we also can't do it with them alone…

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "First, the Good News…" »

30 November Afghanistan Briefing

Colonel Edward Daly and Major General Murad Ali, providing an update on training of the Afghan National Army and recent operations against the Taliban in the Mazar-E-Sharif area of northern Afghanistan, 30 November 2007.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "30 November Afghanistan Briefing" »

2 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Saudi Whiplash Washington Post editorial
The Road from Annapolis – David Ignatius, Washington Post
Middle East Peace through Anxiety – Michael Oren, New York Times
Trying to Change the Status Quo – David Horovitz, Jerusalem Post
Losing Ground to Syria - Rami Khouri, Daily Star
Peace Process Fine Print - Oliver North, Washington Times
Partition at 60Jerusalem Post editorial
The Problem with Palestinian Aid - Mohammed Samhouri, Daily Star
Apartheid, Not Peace – Caroline Glick, Jerusalem Post
Pakistan’s Slow-Moving Emergency – Ali Sethi, New York Times
Pakistan's Dr. Doom - Frantz and Collins, Los Angeles Times
Recruiting: Army Asking for ProblemsLas Vegas Sun editorial
A Failure to Confront Radical Islam - Shiraz Maher, London Times
Political Islam - Jemima Khan, London Daily Telegraph
Trans-Atlantic Divide on Muslim Integration – Marcia Pally, Daily Star
Osama's Echo Chamber - Arnaud de Borchgrave, Washington Times
Warning Tremors in FranceBoston Globe editorial
Sarkozy’s Hard Bargain – Jim Hoagland, Washington Post
Chavez's Electoral Coup - Wall Street Journal editorial
Smart Way to Beat Tyrants Like Chávez – Donald Rumsfeld, Washington Post
Venezuela's Public Enemy No.1 - Sergio Munoz, Los Angeles Times
5 Myths about the Bomb and Us – Jeffrey Lewis, Washington Post
The KGB's Mole Master - David Wise, Los Angeles Times

Continue reading "2 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

December 2, 2007

Blame Canada Sunday

Blame Canada

Continue reading "Blame Canada Sunday" »

December 3, 2007

3 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Gates: The ‘Anti-Rumsfeld’ – Ephron, Hirsh & Thomas, Newsweek
Military Alone Can't Defend U.S. Interests - Miami Herald editorial
What I See Every Day in Iraq – Michael Totten, New York Daily News
Iraq: A Non-Story Remakes the Race – Peter Beinart, Washington Post
Rigging Pakistan’s Election? – Robert Novak, Washington Post
Fuses in Gaza – Jackson Diehl, Washington Post
The Perilous Path to Peace - Mort Zuckerman, New York Daily News
How UNRWA Creates Dependency - Romirowsky and Spyer, Washington Times
For Mideast Peace, Think Bigger - Helena Cobban, Christian Science Monitor
U.N. 'Compromise' on Darfur Rapes – Nat Hentoff, Washington Times
The Limits of 21st-Century Revolution – Roger Cohen, New York Times
Sudan: The ‘Big Offense’ – Mark Steyn, National Review
Sudan: Facing Down a Bullying Mob - David Warren, Real Clear Politics
Saudi Arabia: Outrageous Case of `Qatif Girl' - Frida Ghitis, Miami Herald
Venezuela: President for LifeThe Australian editorial
With Chavez's Hand on the Oil Spigot - Joel Brinkley, San Francisco Chronicle
Justice Department on the MendWashington Post editorial
Give Detainees their Day in Court - Jonathan Hafetz, Baltimore Sun
'I Will Never Leave Guantanamo' - Sabin Willett, Boston Globe
The Army’s Waivering RecruitersBoston Globe editorial
Still Selling our Services Short - William Rees-Mogg, London Times
‘Kozy Steps Up’ in FranceNew York Post editorial
Russian RouladeLondon Times editorial
OZ: A Loss for Civilisation – Mark Steyn, The Australian
OZ: Chinese Policy will Test PM - Dave Peebles, Canberra Times

Continue reading "3 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

As the Stomach Turns

More on the jeering, foot stomping, teeth gnashing academics who love to hate the Army’s Human Terrain System by Noah Shachtman over at Wired’s Danger Room - Academics Turn On "Human Terrain" Whistleblower.

The fight between the Army and academics over the military's social science projects has taken a strange, ugly new turn.
On Thursday, Zenia Helbig, a former researcher with the Army's "Human Terrain System," took the stage at the annual meeting of the American Association of Anthropologists. The executive board of the organization had already spoken out against the program, to embed social scientists into combat units as cultural advisers. And so when Helbig began taking the the military to task for its "inept management and execution at every level" of the Human Terrain effort, audience members nodded their heads in approval. (Here is the text of Helbig's talk.)
But as Helbig started answering questions, the mood turned ugly. Turns out Helbig still backed the idea of boosting the military's cultural IQ -- she just didn't think the Human Terrain program was doing a particularly good job at making it happen. That set some in the audience off…

Coal in all their stockings.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "As the Stomach Turns" »

FOX News Interview: General David Petaeus

General David Petraeus; Commanding General, MNF-I; interviewed on FOX News by Geraldo Rivera on 2 December 2007. Hat tips to Gateway Pundit and PrairiePundit.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "FOX News Interview: General David Petaeus" »

December 4, 2007

4 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Iraq: A Failed CongressNational Review editorial
Battle of the Surge - The Nation editorial
Sustaining the Surge - Martin Gross, Washington Times
Iraq Winter Offensive – Alexander Benard, National Review
Iraq: Now and Forever - Bob Herbert, New York Times
Nuclear Testing Realities - Robert Monroe, Washington Times
A Sudden Switch on Iran's Nuclear Threat - USA Today editorial
Iranian 'Terror' Groups - Dick Armey, Washington Times
Bin Laden's True Priorities - Thomas Hegghammer, Guardian
Shariah's Trojan Horse - Frank Gaffney Jr., Washington Times
A Muslim-Christian Handshake - Christian Science Monitor editorial
Sudan's Grotesque Stunt - London Daily Telegraph editorial
The Brittle Culture of Islam – Robert Spencer, Human Events
Sudan: Not Child’s PlayNational Review Symposium
Barbarian Obscenities Dishonour Islam – Rober Coombs, Sydney Daily Telegraph
Teddy Bear Tyranny - Anne Applebaum, Washington Post
Annapolis: 1 Cheer, 1 Yawn, 1 Cynical Shrug – Barry Rubin, Jerusalem Post
Policy Surge Key to Mideast Peace - H.D.S. Greenway, Boston Globe
Reviving the Cold War in the Middle East? – Robert Freedman, Daily Star
Our Friends the Syrians – Caroline Glick, Jerusalem Post
Revolution in Africa, Deaf Ears in Iowa - Heather Wilhelm, Real Clear Politics
Two Votes in Venezuela - Washington Post editorial
Viva, VenezuelaLondon Times editorial
Venezuelans Rain on Hugo - Wall Street Journal editorial
Democracy Stirs in Venezuela - Boston Globe editorial
Chavez Isn't Finished - Los Angeles Times editorial
Voters Correct Course in Venezuela - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
Venezuela: Letting People Say 'No' - London Daily Telegraph editorial
A Loss for El Loco - New York Post editorial
Cheers to Venezuelans - Washington Times editorial
Venezuela: Good Day for Democracy - Conor Foley, Guardian
Down But Not Out in Caracas - Seumas Milne, Guardian
The Allure of Tyranny - Bret Stephens, Wall Street Journal
A Tale of Two Strongmen - New York Times editorial
Democracy Pains - Ralph Peters, New York Post
Backward March in Russia - Washington Post editorial
Putin’s Farcical VoteThe Australian editorial
Deals Can be Made with Putin – Bronwen Maddox, London Times
A Putin Village - Reuben Johnson, Weekly Standard
Russia: Membership Carries ResponsibilitiesJerusalem Post editorial
No Wonder They Like Putin – Norman Stone, London Times
Sarkozy Beat the Mob – Keith Spicer, Ottawa Citizen
Debating Turkey and the EU - Tulin Daloglu, Washington Times
Gitmo: Six Years, No Charges - USA Today editorial
FISA Reform Debacle in the Making? – Andrew McCarthy, Human Events
War's Unfortunate Bond - James Zumwalt, Washington Times
Don't Need 'Don't Ask, Don't Tell' - Nathaniel Frank, Los Angeles Times
TNR's Iraq And A Hard Place - Ed Morrissey, Captain's Quarters

Continue reading "4 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

Oh, what a tangled web we weave...

LTC Bob Bateman here again. It has been a busy few days for those who keep track of things like journalism and war, and the intersection thereof. This post first appeared on Media Matters and I thought I's share it with SWJ.

There are three things on the plate: The New Republic, National Review Online, and Bilal Hussein.

I will start with the first, and simplest, observation. Several months ago I wrote about my doubts about the veracity of a young man named Scott Thomas, who was then writing for Franklin Foer's The New Republic. The short version of what I wrote was that his stories seemed really fishy to me, and I cautioned about wholly believing these purportedly true stories, and I left it at that. About a week later it was revealed that his real name was Scott Thomas Beauchamp, and bloggers on the right side of the aisle took off in a howling pack, hunting for more information. They found some. Foer and TNR, meanwhile, went into what can only be described as a journalistic full defensive crouch...

Continue reading "Oh, what a tangled web we weave..." »

Where is Lazam?

Lazam Faraj Rwaili, aged 23, joined the Iraqi Police Service Unit in August of this year.

In early November, Lazam was in a contingent of Iraqi Police traveling from their own city in Anbar Province to another station in Salah-ad-Din Province. Sitting in jail in the other station was the most wanted man for their own city: a very dangerous terrorist, responsible for many Iraqi and American deaths. They were going to attempt to retrieve him and return him to their city, where he could be further (and lawfully) interrogated by those with a more vested interest in the information he might provide than his jailers in the other province, where he had gone to ground.

When the police arrived at the station, they soon found their man and took photos of him in jail, proving that he was there. Unfortunately, they could not obtain his transfer because the paperwork had become fouled at some higher level in the police bureaucracy. So they departed to return to their city.

The road between these two cities is not a pleasant place. The US and Iraqi forces have been so successful in pushing terrorists out of populated areas that many have taken up refuge between them. The police convoy came under automatic weapons fire from another vehicle, which then sped away. The police, in several Ford F-350s with mounted PKC machine guns, began a flanking movement to pursue and cut off their attackers. At this point, Lazam, riding in the bed of one of the trucks, was struck by a shot to his left lung. He began to cough up a great deal of blood. His vehicle stopped the pursuit in order for his fellows to render first aid, while the rest of the convoy continued their pursuit. Just as they were maneuvering to cut off the enemy, a US Army convoy came down the road, blocking their fields of fire. The enemy slipped away. The police halted the convoy and tried to explain what had happened, but both were without a translator. One thing was clear to both though: Lazam was in bad shape, and needed help fast...

Continue reading "Where is Lazam?" »

December 5, 2007

5 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Intelligence on IranWashington Post editorial
Good and Bad News About IranNew York Times editorial
Iran and its Democratic FriendsWashington Times editorial
The New Intelligence on IranBoston Globe editorial
Iran’s Nonexistent Nuclear ProgramLos Angeles Times editorial
(Some) Good News on Iran - New York Post editorial
We Still Need to Curb Iran’s AmbitionsLondon Times editorial
Despite Intelligence, Iran Still a ThreatLondon Daily Telegraph editorial
A Measure of IntelligenceBaltimore Sun editorial
Mulling Iran’s Nuclear ThreatChristian Science Monitor editorial
The Myth of the Mad Mullahs – David Ignatius, Washington Post
Time to Talk to Iran – Robert Kagan, Washington Post
Was Bush Behind Iran Report? – Robert Baer, Time
Iran NIE: I’m Not a Believer – Michael Ledeen, National Review
The Right Nuclear Red Line – Gareth Evans, Washington Post
Relax? Don’t, Iran Can Still Build a Bomb – Bronwen Maddox, London Times
Don’t Ask CIA What’s Going On in Iraq – David Blair, London Daily Telegraph
Intercepting Iran’s Take on America – Thomas Freidman, New York Times
The View from Iran - Afrasiabi and Barzegar, Boston Globe
Mission Accomplished When? – Cal Thomas, Washington Times
Iraq: The War on Funding – David Freddoso, National Review
A New Course on Iraq (for Democrats) – Michael O’Hanlon, USA Today
Bearing Down on Democracy – Helle Dale, Washington Times
Unexpected Fruit from Annapolis – Claude Salhani, Washington Times
The Politics of Chicken Littleism - Benjamin Friedman, Washington Post
Some Simple Security Steps – Michael Levi, Washington Times
Teddy Bear Totalitarianism - Joseph Loconte, Weekly Standard
The Russian LessonBaltimore Sun editorial
Putin Rolls On - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
Russia’s Rigged Elections – Michael Weiss, Weekly Standard
Chinese Fill Gap in Romania - Harry de Quetteville, London Daily Telegraph
A FISA Fig Leaf – Mac Thornberry, Washington Times
Gitmo Inmates Deserve Better ProtectionLos Angeles Times editorial

Continue reading "5 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

December 6, 2007

6 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Iraq Report VII – Kimberly Kagan, Weekly Standard
Canada’s Absent Afghan PartnersToronto Star editorial
Iran NIE: ‘High Confidence’ GamesWall Street Journal editorial
Iran Threat Great as EverNational Review editorial
Iran Still a ThreatThe Australian editorial
Benefits of WW III on PauseCanberra Times editorial
Supporting Iran’s ReformersOttawa Citizen editorial
Diplomatic Approach Needed on IranPittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
Getting Iran Back on Diplomacy Track - Miami Herald editorial
Still a Dangerous World – Daniel Henninger, Wall Street Journal
Flaws in the Iran Report – John Bolton, Washington Post
NIE Report is Propoganda Victory for Iran - Robert Tracinski, Real Clear Politics
In Iran We Trust? – Lincy and Milhollin, New York Times
Conflicted Intelligence? – Claude Salhani, Washington Times
Extend Olive Brach to Iran – Rosa Brooks, Los Angeles Times
Contending with Iran - Matthew Levitt, San Francisco Chronicle
Trusting Iran is Dangerous – Michael Rubin, New York Daily News
Facts Derail Bush's Iran Plan - Joe Conason, Real Clear Politics
Forget About Any Iran Strike – Adrian Hamilton, The Independent
How to Keep Tabs on Iran – Bennett Ramberg, Christian Science Monitor
Time for Smart Power on Iran - Arnaud de Borchgrave, Washington Times
Speaking Truth to Power on Iran – Haroon Siddiqui, Toronto Star
Lebanon: A Sellout to SyriaChristian Science Monitor editorial
What to Do in Riyadh – Boot and Wolosky, Weekly Standard
Congo: ‘Different Kind of Genocide’ – Michael Gerson, Washington Post
Kosovo: Dangerous, Unfinished BusinessNew York Times editorial
Stopping Another Balkan CrisisLos Angeles Times editorial
The Balkan Split - Timothy Garton Ash, Los Angeles Times
Ending the Balkan Curse - Ilana Bet-El, Guardian
Putin’s Purge in ParliamentBoston Globe editorial
Russia’s New October - Sylvain Charat, Washington Times
Osama Targets Europe - Walid Phares, Washington Times
Mugabe Need Not be Fatal AttractionThe Independent editorial
Of Teddy Bears and Cartoons - Victor Davis Hanson, Real Clear Politics
Fundamentalists Threatened by Teddy Bear - Leonard Pitts Jr., Miami Herald
Colombia: Our Forgotten HostagesLos Angeles Times editorial
Democracy in the Americas – Roger Cohen, New York Times
A Tale of Two DictatorsNational Review editorial
Where’s the Balance on Chavez? - Bernardo Álvarez Herrera, Los Angeles Times
Gitmo Goes to Court – Rivkin and Casey, Wall Street Journal
The U.N.’s Counterterrorism Opportunity – Michael Jacobson, Guardian
Refugee Challenges - Antonio Guterres, Miami Hearld

Continue reading "6 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

New Interagency COIN Manual (Updated)

Via e-mail, Inside the Pentagon report of a new Interagency COIN manual in the works:

The State Department is leading an effort to issue a draft version of a counterinsurgency guide in the next four to six weeks to help Washington-based government agencies and departments defeat future subversive movements. A final doctrine is expected next year.

The effort follows last year's Army and Marine Corps manual on the same subject.

The new guide -- "Counterinsurgency for U.S. Government Policymakers: A Work in Progress" -- is an educational, strategic-level primer for senior policymakers, according to a State Department official in the bureau of political-military affairs.

He spoke with Inside the Pentagon this week on condition of anonymity.

The guide is different from the military manual, which is used at the operational-tactical level, the official said.

"It's inspired by that but we found that we needed to do some counterinsurgency 101 across the entire government including within State," the official said. He added the draft guide speaks to the importance of coordinated interagency assistance to the affected governments, "to help them provide security and effective governance," and spells out what planning and assessment tools are available.

The United States and its allies are fighting two counterinsurgencies in Afghanistan and Iraq, respectively, prompting the establishment of new doctrines based on lessons gained from these battles…

Encouraging news on a much needed addition to our COIN doctrine database. That said, there is still much work to be done before we have a workable Interagency process in place.

Update: Greg Grant, Government Executive, has more on the new Counterinsurgency for U.S. Government Policy Makers: A Work in Progress manual.

State's Bureau of Political-Military Affairs led the effort, which was informed in part by the counterinsurgency experiences of Australia and the United Kingdom. Former Australian Army officer David Kilcullen, who recently served as an adviser to U.S. Army Gen. David Petraeus in Iraq, is overseeing an interagency effort to produce a civilian counterinsurgency doctrine, which is due out in early 2008.
The guide is the first serious government-wide effort to create a national counterinsurgency framework since the Kennedy administration tried to stem the spread of communism in Vietnam in 1962. At that time, there was extensive interagency involvement in rural development and security efforts, particularly by USAID, which at one point had nearly 15,000 officers serving in Vietnam.
The manual combines current counterinsurgency theory with lessons learned by personnel from State, USAID, the military and other agencies. Drafters emphasized that it is not an academic document, but aims to fill a hole that exists because there is no civilian agency publication on counterinsurgency to complement the new Army and Marine Corps counterinsurgency manual.
According to the guide, insurgency is "armed politics," and while military action is essential to establishing security, only political resolution will lead to ultimate success. The guide recommends that civilian and military efforts join in an integrated "clear, hold and build" strategy that focuses on first on securing the populace, then on long-term economic development assistance -- a clear reference to the counterinsurgency strategy being applied in Iraq under Petraeus.
The guide also emphasizes the importance of providing information in counterinsurgency operations to create a narrative enhancing an embattled government's legitimacy. Such a narrative, it says, "must resonate with the population and be based upon verifiable facts and measurable progress rather than promises." The primary effort must be seen by the local population as indigenous, because only a local government can mobilize the support of its people against an insurgent movement, the drafters wrote.

More at Government Executive.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "New Interagency COIN Manual (Updated)" »

COIN History Class

COIN Intelligence Requirements 1963

With a hat tip to an alert SWJ reader who sent this in via e-mail, we downloaded Intelligence Required for Counterinsurgency from the Central Intelligence Agency’s Freedom of Information Act Electronic Reading Room.

A bit of history and an insight on how some things concerning COIN remain unchanged (excepting the focus on Communist insurgencies) is offered up in this United States Intelligence Board, Office of the Chairman, Memorandum for the Military Representative of the President dated 13 August 1963. The linked SWJ document contains the jpg images of the 11 original pages and includes the cover letter, memorandum from JCS, summary, essential elements of information for counterinsurgency actions enclosure, and countries to be considered appendix.

Other recently added items at the CIA FOI site that may be of interest (see What's New at FOIA?):

Review of Insurgency Problems - 1966

U.S. Intelligence and Vietnam - 1984

Record of Paramilitary Action Against the Castro Government of Cuba - 1961

... or search the FOI database using insurgency or counterinsurgency as a keyword for much more.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "COIN History Class" »

December 7, 2007

SWJ Odds and Ends

While not all inclusive, here are some items that caught my eye and interest so far this week - Meeting Abu Muqawama and the SWJ / AM COIN Academy book drive, Roggio on Iran's ratlines into Iraq, HTS in Iraq and CORDS in Vietnam, Barnett and Boot on Iran and the NIE, ThreatsWatch and Westhawk on State-Defense Africa rift, and Betz on Hoffman on civil-military relations...

Continue reading "SWJ Odds and Ends" »

Our Future Combat Systems?

Today's Washington Post provides an update on the U.S. Army's Future Combat Systems - The Army's $200 Billion Makeover by Alec Klein.

... In the Army's vision, the war of the future is increasingly combat by mouse clicks. It's as networked as the Internet, as mobile as a cellphone, as intuitive as a video game. The Army has a name for this vision: Future Combat Systems, or FCS. The project involves creating a family of 14 weapons, drones, robots, sensors and hybrid-electric combat vehicles connected by a wireless network. It has turned into the most ambitious modernization of the Army since World War II and the most expensive Army weapons program ever, military officials say.
It's also one of the most controversial. Even as some early versions of these weapons make their way onto the battlefields of Iraq and Afghanistan, members of Congress, government investigators and military observers question whether the Defense Department has set the stage for one of its biggest and costliest failures. At risk, they say, are billions of taxpayer dollars spent on exotic technology that may never come to fruition, leaving the Army little time and few resources to prepare for new threats...

Future Combat Systems - Official U.S. Army Web Page

Video Analysis of Army's Modernization Program - Washington Post

Future Combat: The Wireless War - Online Discussion with Washington Post's Alec Klein

Discuss - Small Wars Council

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "Our Future Combat Systems?" »

7 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

7 December 1941

Pearl Harbor Raid, 7 December 1941 - Naval Historical Center
7 December 1941: ‘A Terrible Resolve’New York Post editorial
Iran’s Nuclear Deceptions - Kenneth Timmerman, Washington Times
Keep Pressure on Iran – Clifford May, National Review
Why Believe it This Time? – Jim Walsh, Boston Globe
Nuclear Iran a Matter of Life and Death – Frida Ghitis, Miami Herald
IC Learned from Iraq Debacle - Melvin Goodman, Baltimore Sun
The ‘Arab Street’ and Iran – Austin Bay, Washington Times
Third World War Cancelled – Gerard Baker, London Times
Islam’s Silent Moderates – Ayaan Hirsi Ali, New York Times
Annapolis’s 'Auschwitz' Borders - Louis Rene Beres, Washington Times
Failed Afghan Drug Strategy – Eaves and Owen, Toronto Star
What Not to Do After the Pakistani Coup – Henry Sokolski, National Review
Venezuela: Striking a Blow for Liberty – Paul Greenberg, Washington Times
Challenges for Argentina’s New President – Peter Hakim, Miami Herald
Challenge, Not Pander to MugabeLondon Times editorial
U.S. Needs to Invest More Time in Africa - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
Spain’s ‘King of Democracy’ – Barry Casselman, Washington Times
FISA: Where Does Harry Reid Stand?Washington Times editorial
Taps for Liberties or Security? - Michael O'Hanlon, Washington Times
YouTube Trumps Hollywood on War Films – Brendan Miniter, Wall Street Journal
On TNR and NRO - Jacob Heilbrunn, Los Angeles Times

Continue reading "7 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

GAO Report: Stabilization and Reconstruction

Stabilization and Reconstruction: Actions Are Needed to Develop a Planning and Coordination Framework and Establish the Civilian Reserve Corps, GAO-08-39. November 6, 2007.

Summary

In 2004, the Department of State created the Office of the Coordinator for Reconstruction and Stabilization to coordinate U.S. planning and implementation of stabilization and reconstruction operations. In December 2005, President Bush issued National Security Presidential Directive 44 (NSPD-44), charging State with improving coordination, planning, and implementation of such operations and ensuring that the United States can respond quickly and effectively to overseas crises. GAO was asked to report on State's efforts to improve (1) interagency planning and coordination for stabilization and reconstruction operations, and (2) deployment of civilians to these operations. To address these objectives, we conducted interviews with officials and reviewed documents from U.S. agencies and government and private research centers...

Continue reading "GAO Report: Stabilization and Reconstruction" »

December 8, 2007

8 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Getting Beyond Stalemate to Win a War - Batiste and Hegseth, Washington Post
'High Confidence' about Iran's NukesMiami Herald NIE excerpts
Beyond Preemption as Foreign Policy - Matthew Yglesias, Los Angeles Times
Iran CurveballWall Street Journal editorial
Iran Menace Will GrowJerusalem Post editorial
Is Iran Irrational? - Terence Jeffrey, Washington Times
What Happened in 2003? – William Kristol, Weekly Standard
No Policy to Address Iran Danger – Jonathan Schell, Daily Star
Iran NIE: Bushwhacked – David Horovitz, Jerusalem Post
Rough Estimate – Amir Taheri, New York Post
Making the Ayatollahs Laugh - David Warren, Ottawa Citizen
Pump Up Plan B – Saul Singer, Jerusalem Post
Abandonment of the Jews – Caroline Glick, Jerusalem Post
Israel’s Fear and Loathing – Greg Sheridan, The Australian
New Test for Americans and Palestinians – Rami Khouri, Daily Star
Catch-22 of Palestinian Reform – Keir Prince, Daily Star
Coordinating on Africa - Elizabeth Colagiuri, Washington Times
Sudan: Genocide’s Victory – Eric Reeves, Boston Globe
Hope for Zimbabwe after Mugabe? – John Fund, Wall Street Journal
End the Mugabe Culture of Impunity - Peter Tatchell, Guardian
West Africa’s Narco-Poverty – Antonio Maria Costa, Daily Star
Teddy Bears’ Non-picnic – Victor Davis Hanson, Washington Times
Authoritarians in the AndesNew York Times editorial
Colombia's French Connection - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
Balkans: War or Peace?London Times editorial
Partition KosovoLondon Daily Telegraph editorial
Vladimir’s Vote Variation - Patrick Basham, Washington Times
Islam and Democracy Not Compatible – Tom Plate, Daily Star
British Response to Islamic Extremism? – Dominic Lawson, The Independent
The Torture TapesWashington Post editorial
CIA’s Lost EpisodesNew York Daily News editorial
Morale Shame of Torture TechniquesThe Independent editorial
A Word to Our Readers (Smith Affair) – Kathryn Jean Lopez, National Review

Continue reading "8 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

December 9, 2007

MOD and FCO Sunday

British Army Lessons Learned

More...

Continue reading "MOD and FCO Sunday" »

December 10, 2007

9-10 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Signs of Progress Around the World - Michael Barone, Real Clear Politics
Stop Getting Mad. Get Smart – Armitage and Nye, Washington Post
Khalilzad’s Cautious Optimism - Los Angeles Times interview
All Power, No Influence - James Carroll, Boston Globe
Britain and BasraLondon Times editorial
The New Iraq – Oliver North – Washington Times
Tenuous Sense of Security in Baghdad – Trudy Rubin, Philadelphia Inquirer
Iraq: Can We Guard What We Gained – Stephen Biddle, Washington Post
Afghanistan: Success in Musa Qala Matters – Bronwen Maddox, London Times
WMD Ghost Hunter in Iraq – Arthur Keller, Washington Post
Whitewashing Iranian Nukes - Washington Times editorial
NIE and BushPhiladelphia Inquirer editorial
Renew Diplomacy on Iran NukesToronto Star editorial
The Gulf States and Iran - Max Boot, Wall Street Journal
Is This Really World War IV - Peter Beinart, Los Angeles Times
The Spies Strike Back – Jim Hoagland, Washington Post
NIE Making History - Ariel Cohen, Washington Times
No Reason to Relax on Iran – Jeff Jacoby, Boston Globe
Nine Little Words in the NIE – Thomas Powers, Los Angeles Times
Taming Iran – Jack Kelly, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Keep Pressure on Iran - Michael Jacobson, Baltimore Sun
Meet ‘The Decider’ of Iran – Vali Nasr, Washington Post
Opportunity for Diplomacy on Iran – Joseph Galloway, Miami Herald
Our Blind Eye to Saudi Arabia – Linda Chavez, New York Post
Political Manipulation of the Arab Street? - Joel Brinley, San Francisco Chronicle
Piecemeal Peace Talks – Mike Pence, Washington Times
Why World Needs Democracy in Pakistan – Benazir Bhutto, Christian Science Monitor
Bush, Musharraf and the Rule of Law - Nat Hentoff, Washington Times
Delay, Obstruction and Darfur - New York Times editorial
Slapping Our Latin Allies - New York Post editorial
Chavez Down, Not Out – John Thomson, Washington Times
Opposition's Window of Opportunity - Marifeli Perez-Stable, Miami Herald
Time for Independent Kosovo – Menzies and Harris, Baltimore Sun
The More Russia Changes – Paul Greenberg, Washington Times
Putin Delivers – Boris Jordan, Washington Post
The Anti-Freedom Agenda - Fred Hiatt, Washington Post
The Missile GapBaltimore Sun editorial
Engaging North KoreaBoston Globe editorial
Burma: Fresh Start Needed – Genser and Barron, Sydney Morning Herald
Concentrating on Canadian Foreign Aid – Paul Heinbecker, Toronto Star
Was That Really Donald Rumsfeld? – Hart Seely, Washington Post
Why Should Gitmo Detainees Return? – Philip Johnston, London Daily Telegraph
AWOL Military Justice - Morris Davis, Los Angeles Times
Torture ' A Defining Issue' - Washington Post editorial
FISA Rights that Travel - Ron Wyden, Washington Post
Help Me Spy on Al Qaeda - Mike McConnell, New York Times

Continue reading "9-10 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

10 December Iraq Briefing

Major General W.E. Gaskin, Commanding General, MNF-West, II Marine Expeditionary Force (Forward), speaks with reporters at the Pentagon, providing an update of ongoing operations in western Iraq.

Continue reading "10 December Iraq Briefing" »

December 11, 2007

11 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

The Post-War Election – David Brooks, New York Times
Will New-Found Security Last in Baghdad? – Trudy Rubin, Baltimore Sun
American Troops are Winning – Pete Hegseth, Washington Times
Tehran and Washington Must Swallow Rhetoric – Max Hastings, Guardian
How to Defuse Iran – Leverett and Leverett, New York Times
Facts Get in Way at White HouseH.D.S. Greenway, Boston Globe
Iran NIE: Fantasies and Realities - Tulin Daloglu, Washington Times
Questions of Intelligence – Ephraim Sneh, Boston Globe
The NIE Fantasy – Bret Stephens, Wall Street Journal
Tanks vs. Talks – Debra Saunders, San Francisco Chronicle
Forget Trying to Talk to Khartoum – Nick Donovan, London Times
Africa Must Drop Guilt Card – Bronwen Maddox, London Times
U.N.: Righting Rights Wrongs – Gerald Steinberg, National Review
Help the Peace Corps – Obermayer and Quigley, Christian Science Monitor
Victory via Fuel Choice – Frank Gaffney Jr., Washington Times
Vapid Vassals – Bruce Fein, Washington Times
Due Process for Jihadists? – Andrew McCarthy, Weekly Standard
CIA Tapes InvestigationPhiladelphia Inquirer editorial
CIA’s Dark CavePittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
Wrong Way to Fight TerrorismSan Francisco Chronicle editorial
Starting the Israel – Palestinian Peace Process – New York Times editorial
Creative Approaches Needed for ME Peace – Eric Trager, Philadelphia Inquirer
Gazas Galore – Thomas Freidman, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
U.S. Needs to Transcend Neo-con View - Anne-Marie Slaughter, The Australian
Chavez: How to be a Mad Dictator – David Aaronovitch, London Times
Russia’s Next PresidentWashington Post editorial
Vladimir Putin’s PuppetLondon Daily Telegraph editorial
Putin’s Chosen OneLondon Times editorial
Anointed by the Kremlin BossBoston Globe editorial
The Democratic Roots of Putin’s Choice - Andreas Umland, Washington Post
Kosovo: Canada in Odd Company – Richard Gwyn, Toronto Star
Positive Signs in North KoreaLos Angeles Times editorial
Disinformation on Sri Lanka - Bernard Goonetilleke, Washington Times

Continue reading "11 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

ThreatsWatch: The Fiction of Abu Omar al-Baghdadi

An excellent piece by Steve Schippert and Nick Grace over at ThreatsWatch (Hat Tip ZenPundit) - The Fiction of Abu Omar al-Baghdadi.

Fully engaged in the Information War, al-Qaeda in Iraq continues to put forth its message in Iraq under the umbrella of a notional Islamic State of Iraq and employing an Iraqi actor to fill the fictitious shoes of its purported Iraqi leader, “Abu Omar al-Baghdadi.” While al-Qaeda in Iraq is in dire straits in Iraq - as evidenced by the content of “al-Baghdadi’s” latest al-Qaeda-prepared speech - its information campaign has kicked back into gear in earnest, deriding the “apostates” of the Iraqi Awakening movement (Sahawah al-Iraq or SAI) and announcing a new campaign through the end of January. The United States needs to engage in more creative means of participation in this Information War, exploiting al-Qaeda’s faults and weaknesses beyond dry news releases and press conferences.
In a continuation of its PSYWAR campaign, al-Qaeda in Iraq’s (AQI) strategic and operational effort to maintain battlefield morale and to consolidate its leadership of the broader insurgency, AQI’s al-Furqan Media released a 46 minute long audio file (MP3) onto the Internet late Monday night. The recording features a speech by the notional emir of AQI’s umbrella organization, the Islamic State of Iraq (ISI). An Arabic-language transcript, in Word, Adobe PDF, and Flash, was posted shortly after the appearance of the audio...

Much more at ThreatsWatch.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "ThreatsWatch: The Fiction of Abu Omar al-Baghdadi" »

December 12, 2007

12 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

MRAP: Another Casualty of the Surge – Christian Lowe, Weekly Standard
Powerful Awakening Shakes Iraqi Politics - Trudy Rubin, Philadelphia Inquirer
Who Speaks for Iraq’s Shiites? – Nathaniel Rabkin, Weekly Standard
More Constructive Approach to Afghanistan - The Independent editorial
Taliban Can Lose Battles, Win War – Tom Coghlan, London Daily Telegraph
Britain's Afghan Mission Failing - Simon Jenkins, Guardian
Ticking Time Bombs in Kabul - Wahid Monawar, Toronto Star
A Muslim AmericanNational Review Q&A
Confronting Canada’s Speech Police – Rebecca Walberg, National Review
No Peace in Our Time - David Warren, Ottawa Citizen
Iran Debate Will Continue – Harlan Ullman, Washington Times
Iran Still a Threat – Claude Salhani, Washington Times
Losing Weight in the Gulf – Thomas Freidman, New York Times
Kosovo Deserves Independence – Anthony Loyd, London Times
Politics, Putin StyleNew York Times editorial
Putin’s Puppet PrezNew York Post editorial
Putin and Power - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
Russia’s New Oligarchy – Anders Aslund, Washington Post
Putin Holds the Royal Scepter – Reuben Johnson, Weekly Standard
Hello Gazpromia – Helle Dale, Washington Times
Pakistan Back to Normal? – Bronwen Maddox, London Times
U.N. Force Won't End Darfur Tragedy - Julie Flint, The Independent
Khadafy Inside the TentBoston Globe editorial
South Africa Grows Up – Mark Gevisser, New York Times
Put End to Waterboarding - San Francisco Chronicle editorial
Torture Law is Clear - Baltimore Sun editorial
Too Graphic for the CIA?Boston Globe editorial
A FISA Fix – Michael Mukasey, Los Angeles Times
How to Weaken Al Qaeda - Ken Ballen, Miami Herald
Sea Law Turbulence – Ken Adelman, Washington Times

Continue reading "12 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

Peace, Love, COIN? (Updated Links)

The December ’07 issue of Armed Forces Journal contains two commentary pieces that are harbingers of a debate brewing “inside and outside the beltway” concerning Counterinsurgency (COIN) / Irregular Warfare (IW) operations “after Iraq.” While the two AFJ articles focus on Army and Marine Corps COIN doctrine approved last December and its execution in Iraq, the issues the authors raise will most certainly carryover into a larger debate that will shape our National Security Strategy and military capabilities for decades to come...

Continue reading "Peace, Love, COIN? (Updated Links)" »

December 13, 2007

13 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Surge Success Holds Chance to Seize MomentUSA Today editorial
Here’s the Surge Iraq Needs – Christopher Kojm, Christian Science Monitor
Bring the Troops Home – Maxine Waters, USA Today
Australia: Look Hard at Iraq Withdrawal – David Barnett, Canberra Times
Defeating the TalibanLondon Daily Telegraph editorial
Misreading the Iran Report – Henry Kissinger, Washington Post
CIA Let Iran Mullahs off Hook – Greg Sheridan, The Australian
All Mixed Up Over Iran – Victor Davis Hanson, Real Clear Politics
Intelligence Oversight in Free Fall – David Ignatius, Washington Post
Iran: Danger Averted – Erik Schechter, Jerusalem Post
U.S. Intelligence: Quo Vadis? – Jonah Alexander, Washington Times
AQ: Algeria WarningThe Australian editorial
Arab Bloc Uses U.N.Jerusalem Post editorial
What Abbas Can DoJerusalem Post editorial
ME Needs a Lot, But Not Weapons – Raja Kamal, Daily Star
ME: Building Momentum for Peace – Ziad Asali, Washington Times
Syria Prepares its Grand Comeback – Michael Young, Daily Star
Jordan’s Benign, Stable Authoritarianism – Rami Khouri, Daily Star
On Feith: The Dream is Dead – Maureen Dowd, New York Times
Desert Rape in DubaiLondon Times editorial
Helicopters for Darfur - Los Angeles Times editorial
The CIA Tapes - Los Angeles Times editorial
A Confused Debate over Torture – Mark Davis, Real Clear Politics
Torture's Blame Game - Rosa Brooks, Los Angeles Times
Was Pelosi Aware of CIA's Tactics? - Robert Scheer, San Francisco Chronicle
A Jihad against JihadNational Review Q&A
ME Studies Reform Goes Partisan – Stanley Kurtz, National Review
N. Korea: Symphony for the Devil - New York Post editorial
Putin’s Hold on Russia – Cathy Young, Boston Globe
Law of Succession in Russia – Michael Weiss, Weekly Standard

Continue reading "13 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

Command Changes in Iraq

Robert Burns of the Associated Press reports on senior command changes at Multi-National Force - Iraq.

The U.S. military in Iraq is undergoing its biggest changeover in senior commanders since Gen. David Petraeus launched a new counterinsurgency strategy nearly a year ago.
The high-level shifts come at a particularly delicate stage in the war as U.S. troop levels begin to decline, Iraqis are handed more security responsibility and Petraeus seeks to ensure that the gains achieved over the past several months continue…
With the exception of Petraeus, senior commanders generally arrive and depart with their units, which means most of those now leaving or preparing to leave have been there for up to 15 months.

Command changes / status:

Lt. Gen. Ray Odierno (Multi-National Corps-Iraq) is scheduled to leave in February and will be replaced by Lt. Gen. Lloyd J. Austin III, commander of 18th Airborne Corps. Odierno commands 3rd Corps.
Maj. Gen. Jeffery W. Hammond is scheduled to assume command of Multi-National Division Baghdad on 19 December, replacing Maj. Gen. Joseph Fil of the 1st Cavalry Division. Hammond is now commander of the 4th Infantry Division.
In western Iraq, Maj. Gen. John F. Kelly (I Marine Expeditionary Force FWD) will replace Maj. Gen. Walter Gaskin (II Marine Expeditionary Force FWD) in February at Multi-National Forces - West.
In northern Iraq, Maj. Gen. Mark Hertling (1st Armored Division) replaced Maj. Gen. Benjamin Mixon (25th Infantry Division) in late October at Multi-National Division - North.
South of Baghdad, Multi-National Division-Central will not change commanders. Maj. Gen. Rick Lynch, commander of the 3rd Infantry Division, will remain until next summer.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "Command Changes in Iraq" »

December 14, 2007

14 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Arbitrary Politics on Iraq – John Cornyn, Washington Times
Peace Embraces Iraqi Town - Trudy Rubin, Philadelphia Inquirer
Notes on the Global War on TerrorNew York Times editorial
Magna Carta: 800 Years On, Still a Great Read – Ben Macintyre, London Times
The Great White Fleet’s Voyage – Austin Bay, Washington Times
Ahmadinejad is Being Undercut – Nasr and Tayekj, Christian Science Monitor
Iran: A Third Way – Daniel Davis, Washington Times
Terror Attacks in Algeria - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
David Hicks, Terrorist, To Walk Free – Piers Akerman, Sydney Daily Telegraph
'Sort Of' Independence in Kosovo - Baltimore Sun editorial
‘Indignados’ Exposed - R. Emmett Tyrrell, Jr., Washington Times
In Russia, Post-Putin is PutinChristian Science Monitor editorial
Enabling the Kremlin - Andrei Illarionov, Washington Post
Crackup in Bolivia?Washington Post editorial
Showdown in Bolivia - Miami Herald editorial
Peru: Fujimori's Day of Reckoning - Miami Herald editorial
Cancel Haiti's Debt - Marlene Bastiene, Miami Herald

Continue reading "14 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

December 15, 2007

15 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Prospects for AFRICOM HQ – Valerie Reed, Center for Defense Information
Judging When You Must Fight a War – Christopher Howse, London Daily Telegraph
Afghan Story – John Podhoretz, Weekly Standard
Lebanon at the EdgeBoston Globe editorial
With Spies like These – Joseph Weisberg, Washington Post
All Mixed Up Over Iran – Victor Davis Hanson, Washington Times
Rivalry Transcending Nuclear Iran – Michael Young, Daily Star
A Conversation with Pervez Musharraf - Lally Weymouth, Washington Post
Neutralize Hamas – David Kimche, Jerusalem Post
Bad Idea About to Deploy in Darfur – Julie Flint, Daily Star
Algeria Warning, AQ Wants FootholdThe Australian editorial
French too Generous to Gaddafi?London Times editorial
Improving Peru - Ian Vasquez, National Review
The Perils of PutinismWall Street Journal editorial
Medvedev’s Russia vs. Putin’s – Same Greene, Washington Post
Russia Incorporated – David Satter, Weekly Standard
U.S., Russia as Partners - Getreuer and Sypko, Boston Globe
China Port Power Play – Richard Halloran, Washington Times
Orwellian Left’s Totalitarian Heart – Janet Albrechtsen, The Australian
Pelosi Hits Rock Bottom on Budget FightWashington Times editorial
Mormons, Muslims, and Multiculturalism – Kenneth Anderson, Weekly Standard
FISA: The Court that May Not be HeardNew York Times editorial
Waterboarding: Wishy-Washy Pelosi - Jonah Goldberg, National Review

Continue reading "15 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

A Modest Proposal to Adjust the Principles of War

A Modest Proposal to Adjust the Principles of War

Lieutenant Colonel Gian P. Gentile

I propose a consideration to adjust the Principles of War as accepted by the American military since J.F.C. Fuller first came out with them in the early 1920s and the American Army’s use of them in the majority of its major doctrinal manuals. I do not propose radically new principles of war like Lieutenant Commander Christopher Van Avery did in a recent summer Armed Forces Journal article. His proposal of very different Principles seemed too “new-ageish” for me and in my mind wrongly assumed that the information revolution of the 1990s produced a concomitant revolution in military affairs (a still debated and contested notion by scholars). Too, with regard to Avery, I do not accept his historical premise of now as the time to radically adjust the Principles of War because of the so called recent RMA; one could easily make the argument that we should have produced new Principles of War shortly after August 1945 and the advent of atomic war and Bernard Brodie’s classic The Absolute Weapon...

Continue reading "A Modest Proposal to Adjust the Principles of War" »

December 16, 2007

Wind and Lion Sunday

Part I

Part II

Continue reading "Wind and Lion Sunday" »

16 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Plenty of Blame for AfghanistanNew York Times editorial
No Hope for Victory Soon in Afghanistan – Jason Burke, Guardian
Muscle Alone Won’t Solve Afghan Problems – James Fergusson, The Independent
An Iraq Town Shrugs Off Terror – Ulrike Putz, Der Spiegel
Conventional Wisdom Wrong on Iraq – Victor Davis Hanson, National Review
Coherent Policy, Hurdles Remain in Iraq – Trudy Rubin, Philadelphia Inquirer
The New Iraq – Oliver North, Washington Times
National Guard’s Turn to Surge – Sydney Freedberg Jr., National Journal
COIN in the Philippines - Philippines Inquirer editorial
America’s Priorities in the War on Terror – Mike Huckabee, Real Clear Politics
Even in Peace Iran Will Hate – Greg Sheridan, The Australian
Stuck on DarfurWashington Post editorial
Darfur Horrors Aren’t Genocide – Jonathan Kolieb, Baltimore Sun
Palestinian Scapegoats in Lebanon – Nir Rosen, Washington Post
No Peace in Our Time – Greg Sheridan, Sydney Daily Telegraph
Peace of the Pragmatists – Petra Marquardt-Bigman, Guardian
A Conversation with Pervez Musharraf – Lally Weymouth, Washington Post
N. Korea Optimism Misguided - Richard Halloran, Taipei Times
A Gates-Style Thaw – Jim Hoagland, Washington Post
Serbia’s Self-Defeating Posturing – Ian Williams, Guardian
Medvedez’s Challenge – Ariel Cohen, Washington Times
Congress Must Fix FISA – Michael Mukasey, Baltimore Sun
5 Myths about Torture and Truth – Darius Rejali, Washington Post
In Defense of the CIA – Terrence Jeffrey, Washington Times
Royal Navy Commitment Priorities – Liam Fox, Human Events
Time for Muslim Comedians to Stand Up – Sarfraz Manzoor, Washington Post
Veteran’s Charities Need OversightWashington Post editorial

Continue reading "16 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

Venezuela Si! CUBAzuela NO!!

In a "Small Wars" context but with very serious implications relating to the worldwide Cold War II now being waged between (a) America and the West on the one hand and (b) our new "Islamo-fascist" enemies and some of our "Socialist" enemies from Cold War I on the other, there was a close electoral victory for our side recently in Venezuela.

That South American country's egomaniacal, "Socialism or Death" dictator Hugo Chavez was narrowly defeated in the carefully contrived December 2, 2007 referendum which would have enabled him to follow in Fidel Castro's "President for Life" footsteps. So, a genuine "Hooray For Our Side!!" is very much in order...

Continue reading "Venezuela Si! CUBAzuela NO!!" »

December 17, 2007

17 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Iraq: The Best-Story of the Year – Tim Hames, London Times
Awakening Shakes up Iraqi Politics - Trudy Rubin, Miami Herald
A Civilian Partner for Our Troops - Lugar and Rice, Washington Post
A Realistic and Principled Foreign Policy – Bill Richardson, Real Clear Politics
Failures Force U.S. Foreign Policy Change – Michael Nacht, Sydney Morning Herald
Two Debates, Two Countries – David Broder, Real Clear Politics
Torture Not the American Way - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
Chief Prosecutor: Why I Quit Gitmo - Morris Davis, Miami Herald
Treating Enemies as Equals - William Hawkins, Washington Times
Interrogation Crimes Worse than Cover-up - Rosa Brooks, Miami Herald
Building an Atomic Bomb - Peter Huessy, Washington Times
The Iran NIE Bombs - Steve Coll, The New Yorker
Jihadist Indoctrination in Iran's Schools - Nir Boms. Washington Times
A Real End to Pakistan's Emergency? - Simon Robinson, Time Magazine
Two Months in Pakistan - Lally Weymouth, Washington Post
Questions for Musharraf and Bush - Tierney and Ahsan, Washington Post
Sorting out Australia’s Defence Mess – Carlo Kopp, Canberra Times
Paying Asylum Seekers to go HomeLondon Daily Telegraph editorial
The Region: Survivor, Gulf Style – Barry Rubin, Jerusalem Post
Bush on the Way to IsraelJerusalem Post editorial
Israeli Military Option Failed Haaretz editorial
Bring us War in Gaza – Zvi Bar’el, Haaretz
Israel Will Never be Recognized as a Jewish State – Issam Makhoul, Daily Star
Al Jazeera Goes Mainstream - Ned Lamont, The Nation
The Algerian Terror Lesson - Boston Globe editorial
Egypt's YouTube Democrats - Jackson Diehl, Washington Post
Libya Doesn’t Deserve the Red Carpet – David Schenker, Christian Science Monitor
Mauritanian Democracy Needs Prosperity – Salma Waheedi, Daily Star
Seeking a Leader in South AfricaLondon Times editorial
Russia – Europe: Friend or Foe? – Giles Meritt, Guardian
Challenge in Kosovo - Washington Post editorial
Another Balkans Battle? - Doug Bandow, Washington Times
Belgium: A Surreal State - Roger Cohen, New York Times

Continue reading "17 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

Zinni's Considerations Revisited

Urban Operations Journal – 28 February 2003

General Anthony Zinni (USMC Ret); experienced in the theory, planning, and conduct of Military Operations Other Than War (MOOTW) as well as a leading proponent of cultural intelligence; developed the following considerations for humanitarian assistance, peacekeeping, and peace enforcement operations. The successful conduct of operations in Iraq extends well beyond 'taking down Saddam'. The end state we achieve in Iraq - and how we achieve it - will have a direct and serious impact on all future operations in the conduct of our war on terrorism.

They are presented here as helpful guidelines on winning the peace before, during, and after the dust settles in Baghdad and other Iraqi urban areas...

Continue reading "Zinni's Considerations Revisited" »

From Iraq to Afghanistan

The Washington Post reports today that President Bush is facing new pressure from the U.S. Military to accelerate a force reduction in Iraq in order to increase capabilities in Afghanistan.

Administration officials said the White House could start to debate the future of the American military commitment in both Iraq and Afghanistan as early as next month. Some Pentagon officials are urging a further drawdown of forces in Iraq beyond that envisioned by the White House, which is set to reduce the number of combat brigades from 20 to 15 by the end of next summer. At the same time, commanders in Afghanistan are looking for several additional battalions, helicopters and other resources to confront a resurgent Taliban movement.
Administration officials say the White House has become more concerned in recent months about the situation in Afghanistan, where grinding poverty, rampant corruption, poor infrastructure and the growing challenge from the Taliban are hindering U.S. stabilization efforts. Senior administration officials now believe Afghanistan may pose a greater longer-term challenge than Iraq.

According to NATO's International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) there are currently 41,700 troops (including National Support Elements) in Afghanistan. However, as the Post reports, Britain, the Netherlands, Canada and Australia have assumed the heaviest part of the combat burden alongside U.S. troops.

U.S. Army Gen. Dan K. McNeill, the top NATO commander in Afghanistan, is asking for an additional three battalions of troops from NATO countries -- the equivalent of another brigade combat team -- but colleagues believe that would not be enough. U.S. officials are doubtful that allies will provide all the requested troops, and predict Bush will be faced with a request for even more U.S. troops, possibly after attending a NATO summit in April in Bucharest, Romania.
U.S. officials said Bush may also consider revamping the current military structure in Afghanistan, which has McNeill serving alongside a four-star NATO commander. Restrictions by NATO members on how their troops can be used -- Germany, for instance, limits where its forces can be deployed -- have made it difficult to mount a coherent response to the Taliban resurgence. U.S. forces, which have been largely confined to a small part of the country in the east, have little presence in the south, where much of the insurgency has taken hold.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "From Iraq to Afghanistan" »

December 18, 2007

Future COIN in Afghanistan

New York Times, Washington Post, Abu Muqawama and The Captain’s Journal all chime in... New initiatives, top-to-bottom reviews, additional resources, NATO caveats, leadership and expectations...

Continue reading "Future COIN in Afghanistan" »

18 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

COIN: Learning, Adapting, Applying – Alexander Alderson, RUSI
HTS: Touchy, Feely in the Kill Chain – David Isenberg, Asia Times
Importance of a Strong Navy – Bret Stephens, Wall Street Journal
Turkey’s Harmful Empty GestureBoston Globe editorial
Turkey Strikes Rebels – Tulin Daloglu, Washington Times
Brit’s Basra ModelPittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
Casualties of the Iraq War – Geoffrey Wheatcroft, The Australian
An Afghan Ant’s NestThe Australian editorial
NIE in the Sky? – James Zumwalt, Washington Times
Nuclear Danger Remains Real – Jonathan Schell, Miami Hearld
Effective Policy that Keeps Iran in Check - Rachel Loeffler, Philadelphia Inquirer
Inside the War on Terror – Joshua Sinai, Washington Times
Kosovo RevisitedUSA Today editorial
U.K. Detention: Be Liberal, But Not with Facts – David Aaronovitch, London Times
The Mutation of the United Nations – Frank Gaffney Jr., Washington Times
West BankersLondon Times editorial
Two Conflicts Key to Mideast Peace – DeWayne Wickham, USA Today
Palestinians Need Peace and Aid – Tim Butcher, London Daily Telegraph
A Threat to Israel – Zalman Shoval, Washington Times
Guess Who Didn’t Come to Annapolis – Jonathan Karl, Weekly Standard
Waterboarding and the Left – Jonah Goldberg, Miami Hearld
The Homeles 'Vets' Who Aren't - Michael Fumento, New York Post

Continue reading "18 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

Air and Space Power COIN / IW

The Winter 2007 - 2008 editon of Air and Space Power Journal has been posted and contains several articles that address the use of air power and Air Force capabilities in a Counterinsurgency / Irregular Warfare environment. The first article, by Dr. Conrad Crane, addresses the base-line principles and imperatives for combating insurgency.

COIN / IW

Minting COIN - by Dr. Conrad Crane.

The world became aware of the existence of a coherent body of theory about insurgency as a result of the revolutionary upheavals accompanying the deterioration of empires following World War II. Along with the propagation of ideas from Mao Tse-tung, Ernesto “Che” Guevara, Carlos Marighella, and Vo Nguyen Giap came a corresponding attempt by counterinsurgents to develop their own set of practices and principles. The tenets of these mostly British and French writers were a product of many years of struggle in theaters from Algeria to Malaya to Vietnam, along with observation of many case studies. David Galula, Frank Kitson, Robert Thompson, and Roger Trinquier still have much useful information for current practitioners of counterinsurgency (COIN). Of recent note for anyone trying to learn about COIN from history is the comprehensive work of the Naval Postgraduate School’s Kalev Sepp, who looks at scores of historical cases to develop his own list of best and worst practices for COIN.

Much more...

Continue reading "Air and Space Power COIN / IW" »

December 19, 2007

19 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Officer Retention: The Army’s Other Crisis – Andrew Tilghman, Washington Monthly
Skirting the Abyss in Iraq – David Ignatius, Washington Post
This is not the Time to Backslide in Iraq – Marsha Blackburn, Tennessean
The Sergeant’s War – Ralph Peters – New York Post
Hope for Iraqi RefugeesLos Angeles Times editorial
Stupid Intelligence on Iran – James Schlesinger, Wall Street Journal
Russia and Iran’s Nukes – Peter Brookes, New York Post
Down Payment on Mideast PeaceNew York Times editorial
Canada Funding Mideast HopeToronto Star editorial
Mr. Musharraf’s WarWashington Post editorial
The Choices in Darfur – Michael Gerson, Washington Post
Saudi Second ThoughtsChicago Tribune editorial
Saudi Pardon WelcomeToronto Star editorial
Saudi Arabia: The Wahhabi Woman Problem – Anne Applebaum, Slate
As Kha-Daffy as EverNew York Post editorial
U.N. Abuse in HaitiMiami Herald editorial
Cuba Won’t Cry for Castro – Norman Lamont, London Daily Telegraph
CIA Tapes: A Job for JusticeWashington Post editorial
Sen. Reid’s Stink BombWashington Times editorial
Does Al-Jazeera Belong in the USA – Souheila Al-Jadda, USA Today
Savage vs. CAIR: Free Speech Battle – Cinnamon Stillwell, San Francisco Chronicle
Back in the EUSSR – Paul Belien, Washington Times

Continue reading "19 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

General McCaffrey Iraq AAR

After Action Report by General Barry R McCaffrey, U.S. Army (retired), 18 December 2007. AAR written for the United States Military Academy based on GEN McCaffrey’s 5 – 11 December 2007 trip to Iraq. Highlights from the report follow...

Continue reading "General McCaffrey Iraq AAR" »

19 December News and Reports

Measuring Stability and Security in Iraq – DoD Quarterly Report

These reports are submitted to Congress pursuant to the section entitled “Measuring Stability and Security in Iraq” of House Conference Report 109-72 accompanying H.R. 1268, Emergency Supplemental Appropriations Act for Defense, the Global War on Terror, and Tsunami Relief, 2005, Public Law 109-13.

Executive Roundtable for Economic Reconstruction - Proceedings Report

Organized at the request of Major General (sel.) John F. Kelly, Commanding General of I MEF (Fwd), this senior level roundtable was held over the course of two-days at Quantico, VA on September 19 and 20, 2007. It focused on interagency issues and private sector engagement. The roundtable featured an address by General James Conway, Commandant of the Marine Corps, a briefing on the current status of II MEF (Fwd) from Major General (sel.) John Allen, Deputy Commanding General of Multi National Force – West, and a private sector initiatives address by Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Business Transformation, Paul Brinkley. The roundtable also included presentations from the U.S. Departments of Defense, State, Commerce, Treasury, and Justice, the U.S. Agency for International Development, the NGO and IO community, and Washington Post reporter and author of “Fiasco” Tom Ricks.

Strategy Making Iraq Safer Snubbed for YearsUSA Today

A change has swept across Iraq, and attacks using improvised explosive devices, or IEDs, have declined steadily for eight months. Casualties from the bombs are at their lowest point since 2003, the first year of the war. Troops have seized twice as many weapons caches this year as they did all of last.

2007 Person of the Year Runner-upTime Magazine

General David Petraeus has not failed, which, given the anarchy and pessimism of February, must be considered something of a triumph. The sketchy progress he has made is the result of equal parts luck and skill. The Sunni tribal revolt against the violent grip of Salafist extremists (most notably, al-Qaeda in Iraq) was already under way when Petraeus arrived. But he was smart enough to encourage and fund the Anbar Awakening, even though Iraq's Shi'ite-dominated central government was opposed. The pacification of Anbar, the most violent province in 2006, has been the signal success of 2007.

Officer Retention: The Army’s Other CrisisWashington Monthly

In the last four years, the exodus of junior officers from the Army has accelerated. In 2003, around 8 percent of junior officers with between four and nine years of experience left for other careers. Last year, the attrition rate leapt to 13 percent. "A five percent change could potentially be a serious problem," said James Hosek, an expert in military retention at the RAND Corporation. Over the long term, this rate of attrition would halve the number of officers who reach their tenth year in uniform and intend to take senior leadership roles.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "19 December News and Reports" »

December 20, 2007

20 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Astonishing Iraq Turnaround – Fred Barnes, Weekly Standard
McCain Takes On Time’s Cover GuyBoston Herald editorial
Petraeus Doesn’t Rank with Time – Dean Barnett, Weekly Standard
The Walls around Bush’s Iraq Strategy – Rosa Brooks, Los Angeles Times
Turkey, Iraqi Kurds Must Mend Fences – Trudy Rubin, Philadelphia Inquirer
Middle East Peace Impossible Without Will – Greg Sheridan, The Australian
A Middle East Transformed? Hardly – Gregory Scoblete, Real Clear Politics
Young Egyptians Plugging into Democracy – Jackson Diehl, Miami Hearld
Stability Through UraniumBoston Globe editorial
Vetting the Iran NIE – James Lyons, Washington Times
U.S. Needs to Engage Iran – Haroon Siddiqui, Toronto Star
Forward Defense and the “Hamas Rules” – Stuart Koehl, Weekly Standard
The Spirit of Eid Al-Adha – Nasser Wedday, Boston Globe
Australian Foreign Policy to Change - Michael Fullilove, Sydney Morning Herald
Help for DarfuriansWashington Times editorial
Qaddafi Plays Paris and MadridNew York Times editorial
Why Mbeki Had to GoLondon Daily Telegraph editorial
South Africa Fears Worse from Zuma – Graham Boynton, London Daily Telegraph
A Nuclear Site is Breached – Micah Zenko, Washington Post
Chavism without Chavez – Ken Frankel, Ottawa Citizen
Power Grab Puts Privacy at RiskUSA Today editorial
We Balance Security, Privacy – Michael Mukasey, USA Today
How to Fix Intelligence Oversight – Tim Roemer, Washington Post

Continue reading "20 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

Small Wars Journal Man of the Year

General David Petraeus, Commanding General Multi-National Force - Iraq

Continue reading "Small Wars Journal Man of the Year" »

December 21, 2007

21 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Iraq Seen Plain – Michael Leeden, National Review
Paradox for Petraeus - David Ignatius, Washington Post
Maliki’s Opportunity to Rebuild Iraq – Con Coughlin, London Daily Telegraph
Foreign Policy Follies - USA Today editorial
Bush's 'Axis of Evil,' Six Years Later - Charles Krauthammer, Washington Post
Oil and War Mix – Clifford May, National Review
The Powers of Petrocracy - Fouad Ajami, U.S. News & World Report
Good Will and Armed Vigilance - Austin Bay, Washington Times
Common Sense Needed on Iran – Raymond Ibrahim, National Review
Reflections on the Iran NIE – James Robbins, National Review
Rudd’s Middle East Test – Amin Saikal, Canberra Times
A Ceasefire from Hamas? - Boston Globe editorial
PA: What About the Record? - Diana West, Washington Times
Free Mark SteynNational Review editorial
Why are the Gitmo 3 Britain’s Problem?London Daily Telegraph editorial
Castro Giving up the Reins? - Marifeli Perez-Stable, Miami Herald
A Change in South Korea - Washington Post editorial
South Korea Chooses a New President - London Daily Telegraph editorial
Thailand on High Alert on Crucial Poll – Walker and Farrelly, Canberra Times
Zuma’s Victory May Break Up ANC – William Gumede, Canberra Times
CIA: No Destruction ObstructionNational Review editorial
Bush Yields on CIA Tapes - Los Angeles Times editorial
Let Congress, Courts Probe CIA - Miami Herald editorial
Missile Defense Going Global - James Hackett, Washington Times
Throw out LOST - George Allen, Washington Times
Putin: Odd Choice as Person of the Year - Michael Barone, U.S. News & World Report
Helping America's Heroes - New York Post editorial

Continue reading "21 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

Can the Anbar Strategy Work in Pakistan?

Can the Anbar Strategy Work in Pakistan?

By Clint Watts

Afghan and Arab fighters defeated the Soviet Union by pursuing a strategy that mobilized tribes to entangle a foreign occupier in a hostile land. In rugged terrain, Soviet conventional forces lost their initiative to a ruthless insurgency campaign. Through a decade of fighting, the Soviets ultimately died from a thousand cuts. They entered Afghanistan a world power and returned home demoralized by Muslim guerrillas, hastening the collapse of their regime.

In the 1990s, Osama Bin Laden decided to use a similar strategy against the United States. Spurned by his homeland of Saudi Arabia and vexed by the presence of infidels on holy soil, Bin Laden hoped to provoke the United States into a protracted entanglement in the Middle East. This entanglement, he thought, would increase al-Qa’ida’s prestige and recruitment, unify all Muslims, and ultimately exhaust the United States and lead to its withdrawal from the region...

Continue reading "Can the Anbar Strategy Work in Pakistan?" »

FM 3-0 Operations: SAMS Rewrite

Continue reading "FM 3-0 Operations: SAMS Rewrite" »

December 23, 2007

20 December Iraq Briefing

Colonel Paul Funk, Commander, 1st Brigade Combat Team, 1st Cavalry Division, providing an update on ongoing security operations in Iraq, 20 December 2007.

Continue reading "20 December Iraq Briefing" »

DOD Media Roundtable - 21 December 2007

Secretary of Defense Robert Gates and Vice Chairman, Joint Chiefs of Staff, General James Cartwright speak to reporters at the Pentagon, 21 December 2001.

Continue reading "DOD Media Roundtable - 21 December 2007" »

Charlie Wilson Sunday

Trailer

More...

Continue reading "Charlie Wilson Sunday" »

22 - 23 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Presidential Candidates on TerrorismWashington Post editorial
A Step Forward in IraqNew York Post editorial
Tide Turning in IraqThe Australian editorial
The State of Iraq: An UpdateNew York Times op-chart
The British are Going – Claude Salhani, Washington Times
A Gift form Troops in Iraq - Oliver North, Washington Times
Bush’s Game of Chess in Iraq – Andy Zelleke, Boston Globe
Kurdish Conflict: U.S. Nods and WinksPittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
General Petraeus: Man of the Year – William Kristol, Weekly Standard
Afghanistan War Needs FocusBoston Herald editorial
Failure Blooms in AfghanistanBoston Globe editorial
Poppies vs. Power in Afghanistan – Jim Hoagland, Washington Post
Poor Backroom Boys in Afghanistan – Jeremy Clarkson, London Times
Pakistan’s Tyranny Continues – Aitzaz Ashan, New York Post
Questions for Bush and Musharraf – Tierney and Ahsan, Miami Herald
Holy War Among Jihadis - New York Daily News editorial
The Islamist War on Muslim Women – Jeff Jacoby, Boston Globe
U.N. Bankrolled Hatred of Israel and U.S. – Claudia Rosett, National Review
A Ceasefire from Hamas?Boston Globe editorial
Hamas's 'Offer' - Jerusalem Post editorial
Hope for Peace Next Year in David’s City – Douglas Alexander, London Daily Telegraph
European Ado About Nothing in Palestine - Rami Khouri, Daily Star
Russia's Choice on M.E. Peace Equation - Jerusalem Post editorial
Bush Backs Moscow’s Fueling of Bushehr – Henry Sokolski, Weekly Standard
After NIE, More BMD – Charlie Szrom, Weekly Standard
Exposing Iran's Ruthlessness - David Horovitz, Jerusalem Post
Shine Light of Hope on Darfur – Fine and Scheinert, Toronto Star
Keeping Darfur Peacekeepers - Conor Foley, Guardian
Standing up to Mugabe – Robert Rotberg, Boston Globe
Kenya Votes – Travis Kavulla, National Review
Vote Heralds Break-up of ANC - William Gumede, The Independent
Putin: Man of the Year? – Garry Kasparov, Wall Street Journal
Philharmonic goes to Pyongyang – Terry Teachout, Wall Street Journal
CIA’s Rodriguez Deserves a Medal – Linda Chavez, New York Post
The CIA Interrogation Tapes – Andrew McCarthy, National Review
In Defense of Waterboarding – Mark Bowden, Philadelphia Inquirer
Democrats and Torture – Mona Charen, National Review
Supporting the TroopsWashington Post editorial
Be Ashamed of Veteran’s Shabby Treatment – Joseph Galloway, Miami Herald

Continue reading "22 - 23 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

December 24, 2007

24 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Silent Night, Holy NightWashington Times editorial
‘They Rejoiced’Washington Times editorial
Turning Point in HistoryThe Australian editorial
The Greatest Gift – Laura Ingraham, National Review
Troops’ Gift to CountryUSA Today letters
Stable Door is Open – Rowan Williams, London Times
Good Tidings – Donald Lambro, Washington Times
Christmas 1862 – James Robbins, National Review
Christmas 1947 – Donald Burton, Washington Times
Hollow Greetings – Allan Mallinson, Daily Telegraph
Bethlehem – Kenneth Woodward, Wall Street Journal
CIA: Subverting Bush – Robert Novak, Washington Post
Vietnam War Owners? – Arthur Herman, Commentary
Australia in for Long HaulThe Australian editorial
Forgotten Population – Anna Husarska, Boston Globe
Sudan’s President – Nat Hentoff, Washington Times
A Shift in South AfricaWashington Post editorial
South Africa’s Challenge Toronto Star editorial
Zuma the Zeitgeist – Marian Tupy, Washington Times
Blocking Freedom’s Flow – Steve Chapman, Washington Times
Citizen Diplomacy – Scott and Mueller, Washington Times
Putin: Myth of the Strongman – Fred Hiatt, Washington Post
Jihadist’s Useful Idiots – Joel Mowbray, Washington Times
E.U.’s ‘Ode to Joy’ – Slavoj Zizek, New York Times

Continue reading "24 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

December 25, 2007

Tom Barnett on FM 3-24

Tom Barnett on Counterinsurgency – US Army Field Manual 3-24 / Marine Corps Warfighting Publication 33.3.5.

The U.S. Army/Marine Corps Counterinsurgency Field Manual, with forewords by David Petraeus, James F. Amos, John Nagl and Sarah Sewell. Naturally, I loved this one. I had gotten a sneak-peak preview from Conrad Crane himself at Leavenworth in Dec 05 when I was there interviewing Petraeus for the "Monk of War" piece (and addressing the student body) and finally perusing the book was quite enjoyable. The Sewell foreword is the best by far. Really rocks.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "Tom Barnett on FM 3-24" »

25 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Washington’s Gift - Thomas Fleming, Wall Street Journal
Christmas 2007Washington Post editorial
When Christmas Morning ComesNew York Times editorial
The Brightness of the DayBoston Globe editorial
Luke 2:1-20Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
The Enabling VirtueE.J. Dionne Jr., Washington Post
Greatest Gift for All – Paul Craig Roberts, Washington Times
Hope in Times of WarH.D.S. Greenway, Boston Globe
A Christmas over There – Bruce Kluger, USA Today
The True Meaning not Forgotten – Dennis Byrne, Baltimore Sun
Politics? We’ll Take Good Cheer – Jonah Goldberg, Los Angeles Times
Helping the Needy – David Treadwell, Washington Times
A Gift amid Suffering – Michael Gerson, Washington Post
Now Iraq Needs a Surge of Political Will – Trudy Rubin, Baltimore Sun
Turkey – Iraq: An Unbecoming Appearance – Tulin Daloglu, Washington Times
Pakistan’s Fateful Election – Amir Taheri, New York Post
Saudi Arabia Opinion PollNational Review poll
Thailand in TransitionWashington Post editorial
Putting the Freeze on a Frozen Conflict – Sabine Freizer, Boston Globe
Castro is Losing His Last Fight – Carlos Alberto Montanier, Miami Herald

Fair Winds and Following Seas to All in Harms Way
Merry Christmas from Small Wars Journal

Continue reading "25 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

The Success of the Surge

The Success of the Surge
By David Glasner

The real world, even under normal conditions, is a complicated and confusing place. In war, complications and confusion increase exponentially. Ever since January, when President Bush announced what he called a new way forward (and others called “the surge”) in Iraq and selected General David Petraeus, whose ideas for counterinsurgency warfare, codified in the Army’s new Counterinsurgency Manual which he co-authored, provided the rationale and blueprint for the new strategy, to take command of American forces in Iraq, arguments about whether the new strategy was really working have been going back and forth. After months of confusion, the picture has become unmistakably clear. The surge worked...

Continue reading "The Success of the Surge" »

Pakistani Gun Market

Tour of Illegal Gun Market - North-West Frontier Province, Pakistan

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "Pakistani Gun Market" »

December 26, 2007

26 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

U.S. Foreign Policy-making - Helle Dale, Washington Times
America's Challenges - Harlan Ullman, Washington Times
Heads in the Sand on Iraq - New Hampshire Union-Leader editorial
Looking Back on 2007London Daily Telegraph editorial
U.K.’s Long Haul Commitment to AfghanistanLondon Times editorial
Afghanistan: Into the Valley of Death – Sebastian Junger, Vanity Fair
Interview with Taliban Suicide Bomber – Sami Yousafzai, Newsweek
Musharraf, ‘Safe Pair of Hands’ without Legitimacy – Irfan Husain, Daily Star
Musharraf War on Courts Hurts Terror Fight - Trudy Rubin, Philadelphia Inquirer
E.U. Should Demand More from Israel – Donald Macintyre, The Independent
Israeli, Palestinian Combatants for Peace – Seth Freedman, Guardian
In Praise of Missile DefensesJerusalem Post editorial
Thai Democracy WinsThe Australian editorial
South Korea's Choice - Boston Globe editorial
A Chance to Rein In North Korea - Nicholas Eberstadt, Washington Post
War on Congo’s Women – Maryam Elahi, Guardian
Democracy and South Africa - New York Times editorial
Putin's Cold War - Leon Aron, Wall Street Journal
The Undoing of Spain? - Richard Rahn, Washington Times
Military Commissions: Fair or Foul? - Morris Davis, Los Angeles Times
Tortured Democrats - Mona Charen, Washington Times
Reagan's War, Not Charlie Wilson's - Investor's Business Daily editorial
Charlie Wilson’s War – Peter Suderman, National Review
Charlie Wilson’s War, and Ours – Max Boot, Commentary

Continue reading "26 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

COIN Theory and Securing Iraq

In "COIN of the Realm" (Foreign Affairs - November/December 2007), Colin Kahl divided counterinsurgency (COIN) theory into opposing two schools of thought: "hearts and minds" versus "coercion". Khal cited me as an advocate of "coercion", quoting my observation about "a radical religion whose adherents are not susceptible to having their hearts and minds won over."

Kahl is right; Al Qaeda must be destroyed, not converted. But having spent years on battlefields as a Marine in Vietnam and now as a correspondent for The Atlantic Monthly, I am leery of academic categories. In the actual fight, it's hard to distinguish the 'hearts and minds' from unreconstructed 'coercion'. Counterinsurgency is not an either-or proposition. Kahl rightly praised the Army/Marine manual on counterinsurgency for emphasizing moral behavior. But COIN is still war. It is a bromide to assert that an insurgency is 80 percent political. American soldiers do not win the hearts and minds of al Qaeda in Iraq; they kill them. Killing members of al Qaeda is the essential 20 percent.

In Anbar Province, the heart of the insurgency, the tribes have rebelled against the al Qaeda extremists they welcomed a few years ago. The United States didn't win those Sunni hearts; al Qaeda lost them. The tribes chose to align with our soldiers because, as one sheik told me, "Marines are the strongest tribe." The tribes could not destroy al Qaeda; our military could. To cement the gains, the US military is also acting as an ombudsman for the Sunnis (the "hearts" part) and pressuring the Shiite government we created to provide the Sunnis with resources and assurances. That 80 percent political solution has followed after - and depended upon - the 20 percent battlefield success that was due to the daily grind and grit of our soldiers.

The COIN manual has set the proper strategic tone in Iraq. It has also provided foreign policy elites with an intellectual rationale for grudging acceptance of the fact that the US military is prevailing in Iraq. Nonetheless, Kahl concludes that Iraq remains "a recipe for likely failure" and thus illustrates that even the best counterinsurgency theories cannot change some hearts and minds.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "COIN Theory and Securing Iraq" »

COIN Academy Reading List (Mission Complete)

Small Wars Journal and Abu Muqawama recently commented on the formation of the new U.S. Army Counterinsurgency (COIN) Academy in Afghanistan. We were particularly interested in the Academy’s pursuit of building a first-class COIN library.

So… SWJ and AM have decided to aid in building the library with a little help from our friends. We e-mailed the COIN Academy requesting their reading list. They responded with titles of books and movies that once in hand would go a long way in establishing a world-class COIN library.

To streamline our effort we have set up the Afghanistan COIN Library on Amazon.

Continue reading "COIN Academy Reading List (Mission Complete)" »

March 2008 COIN / STABOPS Conference

13-16 March 2008 - Meeting the Challenges of Counter-Insurgency and Stabilisation Operations: Strategic Issues and Options (Public Event). West Sussex, Great Britain. Organised by Wilton Park, a non-profit-making Executive Agency of the UK's Foreign and Commonwealth Office, but with academic independence. Wilton Park conferences bring together senior policy practitioners, politicians, business people, academics, NGO representatives, journalists and other opinion formers, from a range of countries for informal, off-the-record discussions that analyse recent developments and highlight the best ways of moving forward. This two and a half day conference will examine issues such as the role of counter-insurgency and stabilisation operations in the security policies of allied governments, sustaining political and public support for long-term campaigns, evolving doctrine and practice, the implications of irregular operations for military capability requirements, generating adequate civilian expeditionary capability, increasing the effectiveness of national and multi-national civil-military strategic planning and co-ordination, and developing a long-term strategic plan for Afghanistan.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "March 2008 COIN / STABOPS Conference" »

Charlie Rose Show: COIN Discussion

Charlie Rose Show, 24 December 2007 - A discussion about Counterinsurgency with Sarah Sewall and Montgomery McFate.

Nothing follows.

Continue reading "Charlie Rose Show: COIN Discussion" »

December 27, 2007

27 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

An Iraqi Solution for IraqBoston Globe editorial
What a Difference in Fallujah – Lennox Samuels, Newsweek
Too Soon to Declare Victory – Joseph Galloway, Miami Herald
Surge and Denial – Michelle Malkin, New York Post
War of 1968 vs. 2008 – Charles Zwick, Miami Herald
The Terrorist’s Tet – Austin Bay, Real Clear Politics
U.K. Can’t Rule Out Taliban TalksLondon Daily Telegraph editorial
Questionable Iran PoliciesWashington Times editorial
Fuel for BushehrNew York Times editorial
What’s Holding Pakistan Back – Walter Rodgers, Christian Science Monitor
Middle East BogWashington Post editorial
Bush’s Middle East ChallengePittsburgh Post-Gazette editorial
Hunting for Helicopters for Darfur – Mark Goldberg, Los Angeles Times
Africa: War for the Holidays – Josh Ruxin, New York Times
The GAO on CubaWashington Times editorial
China’s Asymmetric Strategy – Eric Sayers, Weekly Standard
Korea Out of a Corner? – Michael O’Hanlon, Washington Times
A Thai Lesson in DemocracyChristian Science Monitor editorial
Do Burma and Eritrea Know it’s Christmas? – Paul Marshall, Weekly Standard
The U.N.’s Metastasizing Budget – Peter Brookes, New York Post
Police in Though Pursuit – Bruce Fein, Washington Times
‘The Common Defense’Los Angeles Times editorial
Bush’s Very Good Year – Larry Kudlow, Washington Times
Person of the Year Time Warp – Claude Salhani, Washington Times

Continue reading "27 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

December 28, 2007

28 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Wanted in Iraq: A Surge of Political Will – Trudy Rubin, Miami Herald
Avoiding a Hollow Force – Holmes and Eaglen, Washington Times
Gordon England’s War – Frank Gaffney Jr., Washington Times
The Costs of Mixed Signals to KabulThe Independent editorial
Media Military Matters – Michelle Malkin, National Review
A Terrorist’s Tet – Austin Bay, Washington Times
Coal in Israel’s Stocking – Clifford May, National Review
The Arduous Task of Planning Peace – Frida Ghitis, Miami Herald
Charlie Wilson’s War: Not Today – John Fund, Wall Street Journal
Review, Rescind Australia Defence Errors – Michael Costello, The Australian
Beyond the Humanitarian DisasterThe Australian editorial

Continue reading "28 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

Benazir Bhutto Assassinated

News

Full Coverage - Google
Full Coverage - Yahoo
Full Coverage - Dawn
Bhutto Assassinated - Washington Post
Bhutto Assassinated - New York Times
Bhutto Assassinated - Los Angeles Times
Bhutto Assassinated - London Times
Bhutto Assassinated - Sydney Morning Herald
Bhutto Assassinated - Associated Press
Bhutto Assassinated - Reuters
Pakistan in Chaos - The Australian
Assassination Ignites Disarray - New York Times
Turmoil Grips Pakistan - Boston Globe
Assassination Sparks Riots - Washington Times
Pakistan Thrust into Chaos - USA Today
Death Rocks Pakistan - Christian Science Monitor
Bhutto's Killing Stokes Unrest - Associated Press
Bush Condemns Assassination - Washington Post
Bush Condemns Assassination - New York Times
World Leaders React - Washington Times
U.S. Beefs Up Pakistan Force - The Australian
Last Pictures - New York Times
Last Pictures - Washington Post
Last Pictures - Miami Herald
Last Moments Video - New York Times
Last Moments Video - Globe and Mail

Op-Ed / News Analysis

Musharraf’s MomentLondon Times editorial
The Pakistan TestWashington Post editorial
Pakistan Elections Must Go AheadLondon Daily Telegraph editorial
World Plunged Deeper into ChaosThe Australian editorial
From Benazir into the UnknownSidney Morning Herald editorial
Beyond BenazirLos Angeles Times editorial
Bhutto Risked All for DemocracyToronto Star editorial
Death Kills Best Chance for Democracy - New Zealand Herald editorial
Pakistan’s Bitter Political HarvestCanberra Times editorial
Murder and PoliticsBaltimore Sun editorial
Pakistan Must Stay Course to DemocracyThe Independent editorial
Pakistan’s Perilous PathWashington Times editorial
Foe of Extremists Pays Ultimate PriceMiami Herald editorial
Assassination of Benazir Bhutto - Philadelphia Inquirer editorial
Pakistan's Predicament - New York Post editorial
Pakistan on the BrinkOttawa Citizen editorial
Target: Pakistan - Wall Street Journal editorial
Assassination in Pakistan - Washington Post editorial
After Benazir Bhutto - New York Times editorial
The Nightmare ScenarioLondon Times editorial
Pakistan's Perilous Path - Washington Times editorial
Benazir Bhutto - Washington Times editorial
Democracy Assassinated - Boston Globe editorial
Murder and Politics - Baltimore Sun editorial
Assassination Steals key to U.S. Strategy - USA Today editorial
Death in RawalpindiGuardian editorial
The Assassination of Benazir Bhutto - Philadelphia Inquirer editorial
Bhutto's Legacy - San Francisco Chronicle editorial
Pakistan’s Best Chance – Chamberlin and Weinbaum, Washington Post
Pakistan: After the Shock – Greg Sheridan, The Australian
Bloody Reflections on the Dynasties – Graham Stewart, London Times
Tragedy Born of Despotism and Anarchy – Tariq Ali, Guardian
Apocalypse? Mmm, Bring it On – Matthew Parris, London Times
Terror's New Theater - Stephen Schwartz, New York Post
Defying Fate Pointless for Bhutto – Amir Taheri, London Times
Setback for the War on Terror – Haroon Siddiqui, Toronto Star
All Eyes on Musharraf – Simon Tisdall, Guardian
Bhutto's Bravery - Rich Lowry, New York Post
Terrorism Strikes Heart of Pakistan's Democracy - Irfan Yusuf, New Zealand Herald
Tragedy Recasts the Race – David Nason, The Australian
Real World Intrudes on the Race – Mona Charen, National Review
Bhutto’s Death Hardliner Victory – Con Coughlin, London Daily Telegraph
After Bhutto - National Review roundtable
Blow to U.S. Goal for Pakistan – Wright and Kessler, Washington Post
Assassination Shatters Hopes for Stability - Paul Richter, Los Angeles Times
Where Bhutto's Death Leaves U.S. - Thompson and Bennett, Time
Death Deals Blow to U.S. - Matthew Lee, Associated Press
Making a Martyr of Bhutto - Aryn Baker, Time
Can Democracy Survive? - Bronwen Maddox, London Times
Pakistan's Bloody Curse - Saeed Shah, Globe and Mail
In the Mist of Benazir Bhutto - Deborah Simmons, Washington Times
Pakistan Civil War? - Wilkinson, Edwards and Blair, London Daily Telegraph
Bhutto Killing Inflames Pakistan - Wonacott and Solomon, Wall Street Journal
Civil War Feared - Zahid Hussain, London Times
Lived in Eye of Storm - Perlez and Burnett, New York Times
Pakistan at an Uncertain Hour - Teresita Schaffer, Washington Post
Salvaging U.S. Diplomacy - Cooper and Meyers, New York Times
The Queen is Dead, Long Live the Cause – Ben Macintyre, London Times
Bhutto and Democracy – Michael Hirsh, Newsweek
Benazir Bhutto - Andrew McCarthy, National Review
Benazir Bhutto – Max Boot, Commentary
Benazir Bhutto: Headlong – David Ignatius, Washington Post
Supping with the Terrorist Devils - Ramesh Thakur, Ottawa Citizen
Democracy Sidetracked Again - Brian Katulis, Baltimore Sun
Not All are Mourning Bhutto - Tristan Mabry, Philadelphia Inquirer
Musharraf’s Political Future Appears Troubled - David Rhode, New York Times
Roots of Conflict - Eric Carvin, Associated Press
Who Did It? – Jason Burke, Guardian
When an Assassin Succeeds - Rich Lowry, Real Clear Politics
Many Had the Desire, Means to Kill Bhutto - Warrick and Ricks, Washington Post
Main Suspects are Warlords and Security Forces - Jeremy Page, London Times
In the Arms of Extremists - Raheel Raza, Ottawa Citizen
Daughter of Destiny – Christopher Hitchens, Slate
More Peril for Pakistan? - Kim Barker, Chicago Tribune
The Benazir I Knew - Mansoor Ijaz, Christian Science Monitor
The Benazir I Knew - Amy Wilentz, Los Angeles Times
Coming of Age in the Benazir Bhutto Era - Huma Yusuf, Boston Globe
The Traditional Rebel - Molly Moore, Washington Post
Weathered Political Storm - John Burns, New York Times
The Dangerous Void Left Behind – Ahmed Rashid, Washington Post
Benazir Bhutto – Mark Steyn, National Review
Aristocrat Who Championed Democracy - Henry Chu, Los Angeles Times
Grief, Anger After a Voice is Stilled - Trudy Rubin, Philadelphia Inquirer
Bhutto Killing Rocks ‘08 Trail – Allen, Martin and Smith, Politico

Blogs

The Insider Brief - Pakistani blog
All Things Pakistan - Pakistani blog
State of Pakistan - Pakistani blog
Bloggers Pakistan - Pakistani blog aggregator
Analysis of the Bhutto Assassination - Counterterrorism
Benazir Bhutto Assassinated - The Long War Journal
What Died with Benazir Bhutto? - The Belmont Club
Benazir Bhutto, RIP - Abu Muqawama
As Pakistan Descends Into Mourning - Information Dissemination
Assassinated! - ZenPundit
Reactions to Bhutto - MountainRunner
Bhutto's Assassination - Thomas P.M. Barnett
Pakistan on the Brink - Counterterrorism
Al Qaeda Takes Credit - The Long War Journal
Bhutto Shot While Waving Through Sunroof - ThreatsWatch
Al-Qaida Claiming Credit - Counterterrorism
Moving On - The Belmont Club
Thoughts on the Assassination - The Captain's Journal
A Reminder This Is A Real War - Counterterrorism
What Next for Pakistan? - Captain's Quarters
They Finally Got Her - Westhawk
Uppity Muslim Woman Killed - tdaxp
Benazir Bhutto Assassinated - Michelle Malkin
Lethal Assault on Democracy - Counterterrorism
Attack on Democracy - PrairiePundit
Candidate's Reactions - Captain's Quarters
Bloggers React - Blogs of War

Recent Interviews / Op-Eds by Bhutto

Interview with Benazir BhuttoParade Magazine
Interview with Benazir BhuttoWashington Post
Interview with Benazir BhuttoWashington Post
Interview with Benazir BhuttoWashington Post
Interview with Benazir BhuttoWashington Post
Interview with Benazir Bhutto - Christian Science Monitor
Musharraf’s Electoral Farce – Benazir Bhutto, Washington Post
Campaigning in the Face of Terror - Benazir Bhutto, Wall Street Journal
I Will Not Acquiesce to Tyranny - Benazir Bhutto, Globe and Mail

Discuss

Small Wars Council

Continue reading "Benazir Bhutto Assassinated" »

Military Review: January - February 2008 Issue

The January – February 2008 issue of Military Review has been posted to the U.S. Army Combined Arms Center web site.

Featured Articles

Beyond Guns and Steel: Reviving the Nonmilitary Instruments of American Power by Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates. The secretary of defense says the U.S. must develop a cadre of deployable civilians to strengthen the Nation’s “soft” power in today’s national security environment.

U.S. Africa Command: A New Strategic Paradigm? By Sean McFate. The tenth and newest unified command, AFRICOM, stands up in October 2008. Civilian-heavy and with a security-development focus on Africa, this hybrid will not look like its brethren.

Operation Mountain Lion: CJTF-76 in Afghanistan, Spring 2006 by Colonel Michael A. Coss, U.S. Army. The “clear-hold-build-engage” strategy used by Combined Joint Task Force-76 during Operation Mountain Lion (April-June 2006) could be a template for future counterinsurgency efforts.

Protection of Arts and Antiquities during Wartime: Examining the Past and Preparing for the Future by Major James B. Cogbill, U.S. Army. Well before D-Day, America planned to protect European art and cultural treasures. Failure to do the same in Iraq suggests we need a permanent DOD structure to ensure we don’t repeat our mistake.

Northern Ireland: A Balanced Approach to Amnesty, Reconciliation, and Reintegration by Major John Clark, British Army. The political, economic, and security dimensions of societal reconstruction are ineluctably symbiotic. A veteran of the Northern Ireland “troubles” analyzes how that conflict has been brought to the brink of resolution.

The Rule of Law for Commanders by Captain Christopher M. Ford, U.S. Army. Without rule of law there is no chance for civil society and little likelihood of stabilizing a conflict. Iraq is a case in point.

International Law and Slavery by Mark D. Welton, J.D. Human trafficking remains a problem throughout the world—one that often arises in areas of armed conflict and, thus, is of concern to military professionals.

Monitoring and Evaluation of Department of Defense Humanitarian Assistance Programs by Colonel Eugene V. Bonventre, U.S. Air Force. Measures of effectiveness, normally ubiquitous throughout DOD, do not exist for monitoring and evaluating military humanitarian assistance activities. Making efforts to gauge these programs can pay dividends in stability operations.

Threat Analysis: Organized Crime and Narco-Terrorism in Northern Mexico by Gordon James Knowles, Ph.D. Below America’s southern border, conditions are ripe for spawning potential mechanisms of terrorism directed at United States citizens. Awareness and cooperation with Mexican authorities are essential for controlling the threat.

Contest Winners

The New Legs Race: Critical Perspectives on Biometrics in Iraq by Andrew R. Hom. Biometric technology (retinal scans, gait analysis, voice recognition, etc.) is inherently invasive. Using it to map the Iraqi people could alienate those whose hearts and minds we claim to covet.

Finding America’s Role in a Collapsed North Korean State by Captain Jonathan Stafford, U.S. Army. Instead of fighting every battle in the War on Terrorism ourselves, we should help better positioned allies prepare for possible flashpoints. One such flashpoint could well be North Korea.

On Luck and Leadership by Major David Cummings, Jamaica Defence Force. How many times in our careers as professional Soldiers have we heard individual officers described as being lucky? What is this thing called luck?

Merging Information Operations and Psychological Operations by Lieutenant Colonel Fredric W. Rohm Jr., U.S. Army. Merging the IO functional area and the Psychological Operations branch into one specialty may be cost effective. Combining resources, training, and functions can only help improve our effort in the information war.

Insights

Iraq: The Way Ahead by Mitchell M. Zais, Ph.D. Security in Iraq has clearly improved over the last year, but the Iraqi Government has made little progress on the political end. “Soft-partitioning” seems to be the best solution to the government’s paralysis.

Redefining Insurgency by Lieutenant Colonel Chris North, U.S. Army, Retired. The current conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan are more complex than the word “insurgency” suggests. A new definition may be in order.

Book Reviews

Letters

Military Review: November - December 2007 Issue

Continue reading "Military Review: January - February 2008 Issue" »

General Petraeus' Year-End Letter to the Troops

HEADQUARTERS
MULTI-NATIONAL FORCE - IRAQ
BAGHDAD, IRAQ
APO AE 09342-1400

28 December 2007

Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen, Marines, Coast Guardsmen, and Civilians of Multi-National Force-Iraq:

As 2007 draws to a close, you should look back with pride on what you, your fellow troopers, our Iraqi partners, and Iraqi Coalition civilians have achieved in 2007. A year ago, Iraq was racked by horrific violence and on the brink of civil war. Now, levels of violence and civilians and military casualties are significantly reduced and hope has been rekindled in many Iraqi communities. To be sure, the progress is reversible and there is much more to be done. Nonetheless, the hard-fought accomplishments of 2007 have been substantial, and I want to thank each of you for the contributions you made to them.

In response to the challenges that faced Iraq a year ago, we and our Iraqi partners adopted a new approach. We increased our focus on securing the Iraqi people and, in some cases, delayed transition of tasks to Iraqi forces. Additional U.S. and Georgian forces were deployed to theater, the tours of U.S. unites were extended, and Iraqi forces conducted a surge of their own, generating well over 100,000 more Iraqi police and soldiers during the year so that they, too, had additional forces to execute the new approach. In places like Ramadi, Baqubah, Arab Jabour, and Baghdad, you and our Iraqi brothers fought—often house by house, block by block, and neighborhood by neighborhood—to wrest sanctuaries away from Al Qaeda-Iraq, to disrupt extremist militia elements, and to rid the streets of mafia-like criminals. Having cleared areas, you worked with Iraqis to retain them—establishing outposts in the areas we were securing, developing Iraqi Security Forces, and empowering locals to help our efforts. This approach has not been easy. It has required steadfastness in the conduct of tough offensive operations, creative solutions to the myriad problems on the ground, and persistence over the course of many months and during countless trying situations. Through it all, you have proven equal to every task, continually demonstrating an impressive ability to conduct combat and stability operations in an exceedingly complex environment.

Your accomplishments have given the Iraqi people new confidence and prompted many citizens to reject terror and confront those who practice it. As the months passed in 2007, in fact, the tribal awakening that began in Al Anbar Province spread to other parts of the country. Emboldened by improving security and tired of indiscriminate violence, extremist ideology, oppressive practices, and criminal activity, Iraqis increasingly rejected Al Qaeda-Iraq and rogue militia elements. Over time, the desire of Iraqis to contribute to their own security has manifested itself in citizens volunteering for the police, the Army, and concerned local citizen programs. It has been reflected in citizens providing information that has helped us find far more than double the number of arms and weapons caches we found last year. And it has been apparent in Iraqi communities now supporting their local security forces.

As a result of your hard work and that of our Iraqi comrades-in-arms—and with the support of the local populace in many areas—we have seen significant improvements in the security situation. The number of attacks per week is down some 60 percent from a peak in June of this year to a level last seen consistently in the early summer of 2005. With fewer attacks, we are also seeing significantly reduced loss of life. The number of civilian deaths is down by some 75 percent since its height a year ago, dropping to a level not seen since the beginning of 2006. And the number of Coalition losses is down substantially as well. We remain mindful that the past year’s progress has been purchased through the sacrifice and selfless service of all those involved and that the new Iraq must still contend with innumerable enemies and obstacles. Al Qaeda-Iraq has been significantly degraded, but it remains capable of horrific bombings. Militia extremists have been disrupted, but they retain influence in many areas. Criminals have been apprehended, but far too many still roam Iraqi streets and intimidate local citizens and Iraqi officials. We and our Iraqi partners will have to deal with each of these challenges in the New Year to keep the situation headed in the right direction.

While the progress in a number of areas is fragile, the security improvements have significantly changed the situation in many parts of Iraq. It is now imperative that we take advantage of these improvements by looking beyond the security arena and helping Iraqi military and political leaders as they develop solutions in other areas as well, solutions they can sustain over time. At the tactical level, this means an increasing focus on helping not just Iraqi Security Forces—with whom we must partner in all that we do—but also helping Iraqi governmental organizations as they endeavor to restore basic services, to create employment opportunities, to revitalize local markets, to refurbish schools, to spur local economic activity, and to keep locals involved in contributing to local security. We will have to do all of this, of course, while continuing to draw down our forces, thinning our presence, and gradually handing over responsibilities to our Iraqi partners. Meanwhile, at the national level, we will focus on helping the Iraqi Government integrate local volunteers into the Iraqi Security Forces and other employment, develop greater ministerial capacity and capability, aid displaced persons as they return, and, most importantly, take the all-important political and economic actions needed to exploit the opportunity provided by the gains in the security arena.

The pace of progress on important political actions to this point has been slower than Iraqi leaders had hoped. Still, there have been some important steps taken in recent months. Iraq’s leaders reached agreement on the Declaration of Principles for Friendship and Cooperation with the United States, which lays the groundwork for an enduring relationship between our nations. The United Nations Security Council approved Iraq’s request for a final renewal of the resolution that authorizes the Coalition to operate in Iraq. Iraq’s leaders passed an important Pension Law that not only extends retirement benefits to Iraqis previously left out but also represents the first of what we hope will be additional measures fostering national reconciliation. And Iraq’s leaders have debated at length a second reconciliation-related measure, the Accountability and Justice Bill (the de-Ba’athification Reform Law), as well as the 2008 National Budget, both which likely will be brought up for a vote in early 2008. Even so, all Iraqi participants recognize that much more must be done politically to put their country on an irreversible trajectory to national reconciliation and sustainable economic development. We will, needless to say, work closely with our Embassy teammates to support the Iraq Government as it strives to take advantage of the improved security environment by pursing political and economic progress.

The New Year will bring many changes. Substantial force rotations and adjustments already underway will continue. One Army brigade combat team and a Marine Expeditionary Unit have already redeployed without replacement. In the coming months, four additional brigades and two Marine battalions will follow suit. Throughout that time, we will continue to adapt to the security situation as it evolves. And in the midst of all the changes, we and our Iraqi partners will strive to maintain the momentum, to press the fight, and to pursue Iraq’s enemies relentlessly. Solutions to many of the tough problems will continue to be found at your level, together with local Iraqi leaders and with your Iraqi Security Force partners, in company and battalion areas of operation and in individual neighborhoods an towns. As you and your Iraqi partners turn concepts into reality, additional progress will emerge slowly and fitfully. Over time, we will gradually see fewer bad days and accumulate more good days, good weeks, and good months.

The way ahead will not be easy. Inevitably, there will be more tough days and tough weeks. Unforeseen challenges will emerge. And success will require continued hard work, commitment, and initiative from all involved. As we look to the future, however, we should remember how far we have come in the past year. Thanks to the tireless efforts and courageous actions of the Iraqi people, Iraq’s political and military leaders, the Iraqi Security Forces, and each of you, a great deal has been achieved in 2007. Thus, as we enter a new year, we and our Iraqi partners will have important accomplishments and a newfound sense of hope on which we can build.

As always, all or your leaders, our fellow citizens back home, and I deeply appreciate the dedication, professionalism, commitment, and courage you display on a daily basis. It remains the greatest of honors to serve with each of you in this critical endeavor.

Sincerely,

David H. Petraeus

Continue reading "General Petraeus' Year-End Letter to the Troops" »

December 29, 2007

29 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Soft Power: Voice of Freedom – Matthew Kaminski, Wall Street Journal
General Petraeus Q&AFrankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung Q&A
Six Months that Could Change Iraq – Fred Kaplan, Slate
Iraq: Beginning or the End? – Patrick Cockburn, The Independent
Surge and Spin Cycles – Michelle Malkin, Washington Times
Two Allies Renew Afghanistan Vows – Claude Salhani, Washington Times
The Right Way to Engage Iran – McFaul and Milani, Washington Post
Musharraf’s MomentLondon Times editorial
The Pakistan TestWashington Post editorial
Pakistan Elections Must Go AheadLondon Daily Telegraph editorial
World Plunged Deeper into ChaosThe Australian editorial
From Benazir into the UnknownSidney Morning Herald editorial
Beyond BenazirLos Angeles Times editorial
Bhutto Risked All for DemocracyToronto Star editorial
Death Kills Best Chance for Democracy - New Zealand Herald editorial
Pakistan’s Bitter Political HarvestCanberra Times editorial
Murder and PoliticsBaltimore Sun editorial
Pakistan Must Stay Course to DemocracyThe Independent editorial
Pakistan’s Perilous PathWashington Times editorial
Foe of Extremists Pays Ultimate PriceMiami Herald editorial
Assassination of Benazir Bhutto - Philadelphia Inquirer editorial
Pakistan's Predicament - New York Post editorial
Pakistan on the BrinkOttawa Citizen editorial
Pakistan’s Best Chance – Chamberlin and Weinbaum, Washington Post
Pakistan: After the Shock – Greg Sheridan, The Australian
Bloody Reflections on the Dynasties – Graham Stewart, London Times
Tragedy Born of Despotism and Anarchy – Tariq Ali, Guardian
Apocalypse? Mmm, Bring it On – Matthew Parris, London Times
Terror's New Theater - Stephen Schwartz, New York Post
Defying Fate Pointless for Bhutto – Amir Taheri, London Times
Setback for the War on Terror – Haroon Siddiqui, Toronto Star
All Eyes on Musharraf – Simon Tisdall, Guardian
Bhutto's Bravery - Rich Lowry, New York Post
Terrorism Strikes Heart of Pakistan's Democracy - Irfan Yusuf, New Zealand Herald
Tragedy Recasts the Race – David Nason, The Australian
Real World Intrudes on the Race – Mona Charen, National Review
Previous Op-Ed's on Bhutto Assassination - Small Wars Journal
Cleaning Up the U.N. - New York Post editorial
Indonesia: Time and the DictatorNew York Times editorial
Beyond the ‘Big Man’ in South AfricaBoston Globe editorial
Cuba: Old Guard Spy Heads Interest Section – Chris Simmons, Miami Herald
A Tighter Ship at JusticeWashington Post editorial
My War with Charlie Wilson – Gary Schmitt, Weekly Standard
David Hicks is No HeroThe Australian editorial

Continue reading "29 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

December 30, 2007

Gratitude Campaign Sunday

The Gratitude Campaign

Have you ever wanted to say thank you but didn’t… then wished you had?

Maybe you were in a hurry, maybe you felt awkward.

Maybe they were in a hurry, maybe they felt awkward.

Next time say it; it’s easier than you think… and means more than you think.

So visit the monuments, wear your red shirt on Friday,

and keep that yellow ribbon on your car.

Just don’t miss the opportunity to thank the person right in front of you.

It’s not about politics. It’s about service, and sacrifice and it’s about gratitude.

If you appreciate their service, give them a sign.

Full Length Video

Continue reading "Gratitude Campaign Sunday" »

Michael Vickers's War

Very interesting piece in Friday’s Washington Post concerning a central figure in Charlie Wilson’s War. Ann Scott Tyson profiles the young ex-Green Beret officer who was the brains behind the Afghanistan Mujahedin strategy while working for Gust Arakotos at the CIA. Sorry, Charlie. This Is Michael Vickers's War is a good read on Vickers’s next big challenge – "working to implement the U.S. military's highest-priority plan: a global campaign against terrorism that reaches far beyond Iraq and Afghanistan".

… Vickers, a former Green Beret and CIA operative, was the principal strategist for the biggest covert program in CIA history: the paramilitary operation that drove the Soviet army out of Afghanistan in the 1980s. The movie "Charlie Wilson's War," released last weekend, portrays Vickers in that role, in which he directed an insurgent force of 150,000 Afghan fighters and controlled an annual budget of more than $2 billion in current dollars.
Today, as the top Pentagon adviser on counterterrorism strategy, Vickers exudes the same assurance about defeating terrorist groups as he did as a 31-year-old CIA paramilitary officer assigned to Afghanistan, where he convinced superiors that with the right strategy and weapons, the ragtag Afghan insurgents could win. "I am just as confident or more confident we can prevail in the war on terror," Vickers, 54, said in a recent interview, looking cerebral behind thick glasses but with an energy and build reminiscent of the high school quarterback he once was. "Not a lot of people thought we could drive the Soviets out of Afghanistan."…
Vickers joined the Pentagon in July to oversee the 54,000-strong Special Operations Command (Socom), based in Tampa, which is growing faster than any other part of the U.S. military. Socom's budget has doubled in recent years, to $6 billion for 2008, and the command is to add 13,000 troops to its ranks by 2011.
Senior Pentagon and military officials regard Vickers as a rarity -- a skilled strategist who is both creative and pragmatic. "He tends to think like a gangster," said Jim Thomas, a former senior defense planner who worked with Vickers. "He can understand trends then change the rules of the game so they are advantageous for your side."

From Michael Vickers's OSD Bio Page: Vickers was confirmed by the U.S. Senate as the Assistant Secretary of Defense (Special Operations/Low-Intensity Conflict & Interdependent Capabilities) on 23 July 2007. He is the senior civilian advisor to the Secretary and Deputy Secretary of Defense on the capabilities and operational employment of special operations forces, strategic forces, and conventional forces. He is also the senior civilian advisor on counterterrorism strategy, irregular warfare, and force transformation.

Prior to his appointment as ASD (SO/LIC&IC), Vickers served as Senior Vice President, Strategic Studies, at the Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments (CSBA). In this capacity, he provided advice on Iraq strategy to President Bush and his war cabinet. He also was a senior advisor to the 2006 Quadrennial Defense Review, and Executive Director of the QDR “Red Team,” which provided an assessment of the QDR for the Deputy Secretary and Vice Chairman. In late 2005, Vickers conducted an independent assessment of special operations forces (“The Downing Report”) for the Secretary of Defense. He is the author of numerous publications, among which is “The Revolution in War” (2004).

From 1973 to 1986, Vickers served as an Army Special Forces Non-Commissioned Officer, Special Forces Officer, and CIA Operations Officer. During this period, he had operational and combat experience in Central America and the Caribbean, the Middle East, and Central and South Asia. His operational experience spans covert action and espionage, unconventional warfare, counterterrorism (including hostage rescue operations), counterinsurgency, and foreign internal defense.

During the mid-1980s, Vickers was the principal strategist for the largest covert action program in the CIA’s history: the paramilitary operation that drove the Soviet army out of Afghanistan. Vickers oversaw a major change in U.S. strategy, provided strategic and operational direction to an insurgent force of more than 300 unit commanders, 150,000 full-time fighters, and 500,000 part-time fighters, coordinated the efforts of more than ten foreign governments, and controlled an annual budget in excess of $2 billion in current dollars.

-----

Links

Michael Vickers is a Busy Man - Westhawk

Charlie Wilson (Mike Vickers Bonus Edition) - Abu Muqawama

Continue reading "Michael Vickers's War" »

30 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Commander Leads U.S. Troops - Steve Fry, Topeka Capital-Journal
Heroes of the Year – Oliver North, Washington Post
Building Proper Peace in Afghanistan – Liam Fox, London Daily Telegraph
He Could Care Less about Obama’s Story – Reza Aslan, Washington Post
Pakistan: Into the UnknownLondon Times editorial
Grieving for Benazir – Bernard-Henri Levy, Wall Street Journal
Bush's Best-laid Plans - Andrew Bacevich, Los Angeles Times
Pakistan's Blood-stained Democracy - William Buckley, Real Clear Politics
Bhutto's Destiny - Benazir Bhutto, New York Post
Pakistan May Not Make It – Peter Galbraith, Washington Post
Pakistan Won't See the Danger - Trudy Rubin, Philadelphia Inquirer
Unfortunate Allies - Lisa Schiffren, National Review
How a ‘Wisp of a Girl’ Conquered Pakistan – Mohammed Hanif, New York Times
As PM, Bhutto Did Little – Jemima Khan, London Daily Telegraph
Pakistan an al-Qaeda Target Now - Trudy Rubin, Miami Herald
Assassin Killed West’s Foreign Policy Too – Michael Portillo, London Times
Climax of a Grim Year in Pakistan – Claude Salhani, Washington Times
Saving Pakistan From Itself - Adil Najam, New York Daily News
Pakistan Politics Played Out in Britain – Matthew d’Acona, London Daily Telegraph
Peace Talks Skirt Housing Issue - Boston Herald editorial
Palestinians: Good Money After Bad - Shmuel Rosner, New York Post
Pelosi and Syria – James Zumwalt, Washington Times
Endless Conflict in West Sahara – Ahmed Charai, Washington Times
Humanizing the Revolution in Venezuela – Enrique Krauze, New York Times
So Who, Exactly, Voted for Putin? – Tom Keane, Boston Globe
Poles Get Cold Feet on Missile DefenseNew York Times editorial
Waterboarding: A Clarification - Mark Bowden, Philadelphia Inquirer
TSA: Most Hated in Government - Kyle Smith, New York Post

Continue reading "30 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

December 31, 2007

31 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup

Well Done, Soldiers - General George Casey Jr., New York Daily News
General Petraeus on Iraq Progress - Ralph Peters, New York Post
Make-or-Break Time in Iraq? - Jackson Diehl, Washington Post
Midlevel Officers Show Enterprise in Iraq – Greg Jaffe, Wall Street Journal
Surge 101: Lessons from Iraq – Michael Barone, National Review
Demagoging Pakistan's Crisis - Washington Times editorial
Pakistan: A Monster Unleashed - Ottawa Citizen editorial
Pakistan: On America's Watch - Roger Cohen, New York Times
What about Pakistan’s Nukes? – Graham Allison, Newsweek
Musharraf, Army Should Step Aside Now – William Maley, The Australian
Can Musharraf Survive? – Ron Moreau, Newsweek
Reform Pakistan’s Only Hope – Chamberlain and Weinbaum, Sydney Morning Herald
Pakistan’s Political Void – Kevin Whitelaw, U.S. News and World Report
Pakistan in a Vortex - Arnaud de Borchgrave, Washington Times
What Bhutto Was Worried About - Robert Novak, Washington Post
Why Mrs. Bhutto Had to Die - Walid Phares, Washington Times
Bhutto of Greater Use as Martyr – Ralph Peters, The Australian
U.S. Failed Benazir Bhutto - John Nichols, Toronto Star
Pakistan Deserves Better - Tariq Ali, The Independent
Good May Emerge from Pakistan Disaster – Paul Sheehan, Sydney Morning Herald
Pakistan: Long-term Instability? - Christine Fair, Washington Times
Daughter of Destiny Becomes a Martyr - Clarence Page, Chicago Tribune
Born to Rule, Not Just in Pakistan - Yasmin Alibhai-Brown, The Independent
About That Peace Process - New York Times editorial
Democracy: An Existential Threat? - Abunimah and Barghouti, Guardian
Kenya: President without Moral Authority - The Independent editorial
A Billionaire's Comeback in Thailand? - Tom Fawthrop, Guardian
Aid Restrictions Killing E. Timor Women – Emily Maguire, Sydney Morning Herald
George Smiley's War - Donald Gregg, Washington Post
Beijing's Blood-drenched Olympics - Nat Hentoff, Washington Times

Continue reading "31 December SWJ Op-Ed Roundup" »

30 December Iraq Briefing

Rear Admiral Gregory Smith, Director of the MNF-I Communications Division, providing an operational update from Baghdad on 30 December 2007.

Continue reading "30 December Iraq Briefing" »